Videogum Home - designed by Guilherme Rosa

 

August 12, 2009

Duh Aficionado Magazine: "Dudeism" Is Not A Religion

Nope. No. Oh, I hate everything about this!

As far as The Big Lebowski is concerned, it is a sometimes funny, always odd movie. It is probably worth seeing a couple of times just to sort of wrap your mind around it. But in the end it is still just a movie. You can buy in on DVD, and you can watch it whenever. You are an adult. But you don't need to become an obsessive about it, who alienates his friends and family with his need to belong to a slap-dash counter-culture that really only exists because there was so little to grab onto in the late '90s. "Do you want to go to the Big Lebowski convention, or the Ally McBeal convention?" "Who cares?"

And as far as this whole "it is a religion thing," a) no, it is not a religion, and b) it will never be a religion, and c) no matter how many other religions this guy is supposedly a Professor of Religions about. UNIMPRESSED! You're part of a fan club, sir. You are trying to teach people the happiness of living as part of a fan club. And I would also like you to show me where in the Dudeism Torah it teaches you that one of the key tenets of your moral philosophy is that you should take part in a viral marketing campaign for a car company?

"Huh?"
--God

Walking around in a robe all day. Come on! (Via TheAwl.)

Posted by Gabe at 4:15 PM in
Tags:  |  |  |  |




111 Comments

38-year olds, Dude.

Posted by: dafs profile link at 08/12/09 4:19 PM  | Reply
Score = 15 Vote up Vote down

Yeah, well, you know, that's just, like, your opinion, man.

Posted by: woozefa profile link at 08/12/09 4:21 PM  | Reply
Score = 53 Vote up Vote down

As a lifelong atheist, I gotta say, this is pretty appealling.

Posted by: Napoleon Complex profile link at 08/12/09 4:21 PM  | Reply
Score = 8 Vote up Vote down

The dude does not abide!

Posted by: Leibniz profile link at 08/12/09 4:23 PM  | Reply
Score = 6 Vote up Vote down

The Dude drives a Ford. This is a thing that I know.

Posted by: Trevor profile link at 08/12/09 4:24 PM  | Reply
Score = 5 Vote up Vote down

This is still more real than Scientology...

Posted by: Captain Boring of the S.S. Shut Up profile link at 08/12/09 4:26 PM  | Reply
Score = 41 Vote up Vote down

Ordained by WHOM, dude? Nice jellies.

Posted by: Becca profile link at 08/12/09 4:27 PM  | Reply
Score = 10 Vote up Vote down

Hopefully wearing clear Jellies will be what starts getting Dudeists martyred or thrown to lions.
(i'm angry I had to type "dudeist")

Posted by: bryan profile link  in reply to  Becca's comment at 08/12/09 4:41 PM  | Reply
Score = 6 Vote up Vote down

This comment's sole purpose is to commend your new choice of avatar.

Posted by: Sedusa profile link  in reply to  Becca's comment at 08/12/09 7:55 PM  | Reply
Score = 5 Vote up Vote down

I was already sighing so much, that once the Volkswagen logo came on screen i just passed out for a few minutes.

Posted by: Elliot profile link at 08/12/09 4:29 PM  | Reply
Score = 13 Vote up Vote down

I bet you're going to blaspheme Sobchakianism next, huh?


Selah. This is what happens when you fuck a stranger in the ass! Amen.

Posted by: Godsauce profile link at 08/12/09 4:29 PM  | Reply
Score = 8 Vote up Vote down

The Dude did not hug other dudes who clearly had no interest in being hugged, just because they were also wearing bathrobes.
Anyway, the one we should all be emulating is Donny: Do your very best to understand what's going on, even when the world repeatedly tells you to shut the fuck up.

Posted by: Lord Growing profile link at 08/12/09 4:30 PM  | Reply
Score = 20 Vote up Vote down

...And then they foreclosed on his house.

Posted by: Sharky profile link at 08/12/09 4:31 PM  | Reply
Score = 9 Vote up Vote down

This made me Lots Of Love so much. Kudos, man!

Posted by: Napoleon Complex profile link  in reply to  Sharky's comment at 08/17/09 2:40 PM  | Reply
Score = -1 Vote up Vote down

"see film differently" = misinterpret film differently.

Posted by: todd gack profile link at 08/12/09 4:32 PM  | Reply
Score = 12 Vote up Vote down

Better this than, like, Gummo. I guess. I like the big lebowski. I like it a lot. But I bet watching it with a guy like him would be hellacious.

Posted by: Silvio profile link at 08/12/09 4:36 PM  | Reply
Score = 4 Vote up Vote down

If his shirt was actually the cover of Idiocracy, this would make a lot more sense.

Posted by: tiredandwired profile link at 08/12/09 4:37 PM  | Reply
Score = 2 Vote up Vote down

We need to talk.
––God

Posted by: technojeremy profile link at 08/12/09 4:38 PM  | Reply
Score = 17 Vote up Vote down

Look who it is!

Posted by: Godsauce profile link  in reply to  technojeremy's comment at 08/12/09 4:43 PM  | Reply
Score = 17 Vote up Vote down

relax.

Posted by: practicallyinformation profile link  in reply to  Godsauce's comment at 08/12/09 4:48 PM  | Reply
Score = 22 Vote up Vote down

I heard that in the voice of Jon Benjamin, which made it so much better.

Posted by: Godsauce profile link  in reply to  practicallyinformation's comment at 08/12/09 4:59 PM  | Reply
Score = 6 Vote up Vote down

JEZ! Have you been relaxing much?

Posted by: jawbone profile link  in reply to  technojeremy's comment at 08/12/09 4:49 PM  | Reply
Score = 9 Vote up Vote down

This is better than the time Verne Troyer commented.

Posted by: .bryan. profile link  in reply to  technojeremy's comment at 08/13/09 3:14 AM  | Reply
Score = 4 Vote up Vote down

I don't understand people who do this sort of thing. I suppose there's some need in everyone to belong to something, but this is ridiculous. If you are too much of a coward to tell people you're an atheist, just tell them you're a narcissist. It'll save you the time of making up a complex philosophical scheme based on Apple Jacks or Ghostbusters and the net effect is the same.

Posted by: scrolllox at 08/12/09 4:42 PM  | Reply
Score = 4 Vote up Vote down

or a nihilist

Posted by: Silvio profile link  in reply to  scrolllox's comment at 08/12/09 4:59 PM  | Reply
Score = 4 Vote up Vote down

nihilism? that must be exausting.

Posted by: the dust collector profile link  in reply to  Silvio's comment at 08/13/09 10:52 AM  | Reply
Score = 3 Vote up Vote down

really, it's nothing.

Posted by: tanaise profile link  in reply to  the dust collector's comment at 08/13/09 11:03 AM  | Reply
Score = 6 Vote up Vote down

Take it easy, man.

Posted by: Mark at 08/12/09 4:57 PM  | Reply
Score = 1 Vote up Vote down

Whatever, I don't judge. I could actual get behind this if they sponsored a group of underprivileged inner-city children, and yes, you guessed it, called them The Little Lebowski Urban Achievers.

Posted by: Deezey profile link at 08/12/09 5:00 PM  | Reply
Score = 8 Vote up Vote down

This guy is really out of his element.

Posted by: Beardzoid profile link at 08/12/09 5:01 PM  | Reply
Score = 8 Vote up Vote down

I never realized The Big Lebowski was an independent film.

Posted by: avettwhore profile link at 08/12/09 5:09 PM  | Reply
Score = 6 Vote up Vote down

What the fuck is he talking about, Dude?

Posted by: PURPLE_DRANK profile link at 08/12/09 5:38 PM  | Reply
Score = 1 Vote up Vote down

As someone who has seen this movie at least two dozen times (DO NOT JUDGE. Actually, yes, judge), I can honestly say that this movie teaches you absolutely nothing. Nothing at all. No life messages, no bigger picture. It's funny. That's all. If you're reaching for something bigger in that movie, then you are severely missing the point. Also, you are a loser. Also also, shut up and get a job, goldbricker.

Posted by: kiss the pan profile link at 08/12/09 6:02 PM  | Reply
Score = 14 Vote up Vote down

Sometimes funny? I don't want to start any religions based around it, but I doubt Gabe could name any movies funnier than Lebowski.

Posted by: MK at 08/12/09 6:07 PM  | Reply
Score = 5 Vote up Vote down

Wait, nobody cares about the part where this was supposed to be exemplary of how Volkswagen "supports independent cinema" (whatever that is)? I thought that was a highly suspect moment.

Posted by: whoawhoawhoa profile link at 08/12/09 6:10 PM  | Reply
Score = 1 Vote up Vote down

see comment by avettwhore above

Posted by: PURPLE_DRANK profile link  in reply to  whoawhoawhoa's comment at 08/12/09 6:43 PM  | Reply
Score = 2 Vote up Vote down

Wait, nobody besides avettwhore cares... by which I mean thanks for the heads up.

Posted by: whoawhoawhoa profile link  in reply to  PURPLE_DRANK's comment at 08/12/09 7:03 PM  | Reply
Score = 4 Vote up Vote down

As an ardent Finkist, I can totally relate.

Posted by: Gary Meadows profile link at 08/12/09 6:17 PM  | Reply
Score = 2 Vote up Vote down

I feel the same way about Alien vs. Predator.

Posted by: jimjbollocks profile link at 08/12/09 6:20 PM  | Reply
Score = 17 Vote up Vote down

Seriously though, I'm a big fan of the Coens. Their movies are generally excellent. But what is it about The Big Lebowski that attracts all the crazies?

Posted by: Gary Meadows profile link at 08/12/09 6:22 PM  | Reply
Score = 7 Vote up Vote down

Seriously, I don't get it.

Posted by: ber profile link  in reply to  Gary Meadows's comment at 08/13/09 9:02 AM  | Reply
Score = 1 Vote up Vote down

Also, I was way more excited about this before I played the video and thought it was pronounced DOODYISM.

Posted by: Captain Boring of the S.S. Shut Up profile link at 08/12/09 6:26 PM  | Reply
Score = 6 Vote up Vote down

I've known Oliver Benjamin since I was five years old. He's a brilliant writer with a great sense of humor. He started this 'religion' after writing a book that studied the different theologies of the world. If you don't get his sense of humor, that's cool. I'm sure he wouldn't give a shit.

But don't think for a second that he's some kind of nutjob. It's satire, fucknuts.

Posted by: Joe Spencer at 08/12/09 6:26 PM  | Reply
Score = -8 Vote up Vote down

Let's all get under the covers and sob.

Posted by: Silvio profile link  in reply to  Joe Spencer's comment at 08/12/09 6:39 PM  | Reply
Score = 5 Vote up Vote down

No. Satire is writing a pamphlet about how you can solve Ireland's overpopulation problem by eating Irish babies. Actually going around eating Irish babies and trying to recruit people to your baby-eating cause is cannibalism, no matter how much you try to tell everyone you're only eating them ironically.

Posted by: Professor English  in reply to  Joe Spencer's comment at 08/12/09 6:47 PM  | Reply
Score = 21 Vote up Vote down

so i should stop then?

Posted by: gulliver  in reply to  Professor English's comment at 08/12/09 6:48 PM  | Reply
Score = 13 Vote up Vote down

This comment was made funnier by the fact that it's by "Professor English."

Posted by: lemonne profile link  in reply to  Professor English's comment at 08/13/09 12:47 PM  | Reply
Score = 1 Vote up Vote down

"I've known Oliver Benjamin since I was five years old..."
-Joe Spencer.

1st off, thank you so much for the superfluous information.
2ndly, you're too late, I already thought he was a nut job for 1 second (you gotta move faster, Joe Spencer. This- is- the INTERNET)
3rd & also lastly, this agression will not stand! (seriously dude relax- Oliver Benjamin's life is not in our hands)

Posted by: PURPLE_DRANK profile link  in reply to  Joe Spencer's comment at 08/12/09 7:00 PM  | Reply
Score = 6 Vote up Vote down

Well played. You win a pair of skinny jeans and tix to the Fuck Buttons.

Posted by: Joe Spencer  in reply to  PURPLE_DRANK's comment at 08/12/09 7:29 PM  | Reply
Score = -3 Vote up Vote down

I'll take those tickets if he doesn't want them, but the jeans are too small for me so he can keep them.

Posted by: Manvnature profile link  in reply to  Joe Spencer's comment at 08/12/09 10:47 PM  | Reply
Score = 3 Vote up Vote down

it's just Fuck Buttons, sir. no "the," unless you wanted to say you were going to THE Fuck Buttons concert. then there would need "the" before Fuck Buttons... way to unnecessarily hate on the hipsters, though. points for originality there... you're el worsto.

Posted by: videogUGHmmie bear  in reply to  Joe Spencer's comment at 08/13/09 12:59 AM  | Reply
Score = -1 Vote up Vote down

Thanks Joe Spencer * *:-) I'll keep the FUCK BUTTONS Tix (I have no shame), but skinny jeans make me look like, well... an adult wearing skinny jeans (ok, I guess I have some shame.*)

*no offense to those who love them; love as thou wilt. It's just that I simply can't pull off that look; my hips are too wide.
** p.s. I still think you need to relax (a little more) It's ok that not everyone gets your friends joke.

Posted by: PURPLE_DRANK profile link  in reply to  Joe Spencer's comment at 08/13/09 12:12 PM  | Reply
Score = 3 Vote up Vote down

Jeff Bridges is the spokesperson for HYUNDAI. I hope appreciation of irony is a major facet of that religion.

Posted by: Skillet profile link at 08/12/09 6:57 PM  | Reply
Score = 13 Vote up Vote down

But Peter Stormare (Uli the Nihilist/Karl Hungus) did those "Unpimp my ride" commercials for Volkswagen a few years back (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cv157ZIInUk). I think this should be Hungusism instead then. Say what you want about the tenets of Hungusism, but at least they would walk around with ferrets on leashes and fix people's cable instead of bum around in robes and jellies and smoke pot all day.

Posted by: kiss the pan profile link  in reply to  Skillet's comment at 08/12/09 8:27 PM  | Reply
Score = 3 Vote up Vote down

yeah, but having a wild... for domestic.... that ain't legal either.

Posted by: Skillet profile link  in reply to  kiss the pan's comment at 08/12/09 8:59 PM  | Reply
Score = 1 Vote up Vote down

Single female lawyer / Fighting for her client / Wearing sexy mini-skirts / And being self-reliant

Posted by: John Ham profile link at 08/12/09 6:58 PM  | Reply
Score = 6 Vote up Vote down

Your revolution is over, Mr. Benjamin. Condolences. The bums lost. My advice is to do what your parents did; get a job, sir. The bums will always lose.

Posted by: Do you have bikes? profile link at 08/12/09 7:24 PM  | Reply
Score = 8 Vote up Vote down

I make it a practice not to take religious advice from men in jelly shoes.

Posted by: Sedusa profile link at 08/12/09 7:53 PM  | Reply
Score = 3 Vote up Vote down

Hey Joe, thanks for sticking up for me. You're a good man and thorough.

What's with all the vitriol? Because we call our fan club a religion? What else are other religions but overblown fan clubs? And they are fan clubs for equally fictitious characters, I might add. At least we're not telling anyone how they must live their lives or any bullshit about the nature of the universe.

If any of you don't find the film inspiring then that's a shame. The world is full of things to be inspired by and many people find The Big Lebowski deeply inspiring. You can be inspired by whatever you like. Why get so worked up over what other people find meaningful?

It's my belief that Dudeism (i.e. a current of thought implicit in The Big Lebowski) is simply an updated form of Taoism with a bit of Zen thrown in, plus some other things. You can believe it's a piece of crap. It don't matter to the Dudeist. Rant all you want if it makes you feel righteous. Wouldn't it be better to try and understand what people find so intriguing about the film than just whinge about how lame they are?

Certainly the argument that Dudeism is philosophy rather than a religion is a valid one. But "religion" is one of those words that is impossible to pin down, like "God" or "funny" or - of course - "dude."

We're happy to call it a religion because it neatly fills a void that moribund traditional religions have left behind. Also, it's certainly more fun and intriguing if you call it a religion. And yes, it is a bit satirical. But self-parody and irony are a fundamental part of Taoism, and hence, Dudeism.

If you don't get the joke, then you won't get the religion either. That's cool. We'll abide with or without you, but we'd rather have compeers than f**king adversaries.

Posted by: Oliver Benjamin at 08/12/09 8:05 PM  | Reply
Score = -3 Vote up Vote down

yeah, yeah, your argument is all well and good. it's the part where you shill for volkswagon that doesn't make any sense.

Posted by: lizzing profile link  in reply to  Oliver Benjamin's comment at 08/12/09 8:22 PM  | Reply
Score = 11 Vote up Vote down

Hmmm. Interesting post. Is it really "abiding" to write such a lengthy defense, though? I'm not a Dudeist, so correct me if I'm wrong, but I have seen The Big Lebowski several times and it seems like going on internet patrol to defend your religion from anonymous internet comments is a little more proactive than the Dude would advise, yes?

Posted by: 152637489  in reply to  Oliver Benjamin's comment at 08/12/09 8:23 PM  | Reply
Score = 9 Vote up Vote down

It's satirical? So basically, you have created a religion (at least in part) to mock other religions, which many people believe in sincerely, but you get upset when people mock the religion that you don't sincerely believe in and acknowledge that you made up? Woof.

I will admit that "Dudespaper" made me laugh. I would probably like you in person.

Posted by: Castlevanian  in reply to  Oliver Benjamin's comment at 08/12/09 9:14 PM  | Reply
Score = 10 Vote up Vote down

I'm not sure I agree with you a hundred percent on your police work there, Oliver.

Wait, no, I think i did that wrong, I'm gonna try again:

Whatcha got ain't nothin new. This blog's hard on people, you can't stop what's coming, it ain't all waiting on you. That's vanity.

Damn, I suck at this.

Posted by: Christopher profile link  in reply to  Oliver Benjamin's comment at 08/12/09 11:02 PM  | Reply
Score = 0 Vote up Vote down

Dear Oliver Benjamin,

I can see why Joe Spencer has been a fan of you since he was 5, you actually sound like a cool guy. However, Joe Spencer was acting very undude. His explanation of the book, praise of your research skills, and writing ability were perfectly justified- it's when he called us all "fuck nuts" that I thought to myself- hey, "Over the Line!!"

Seriously- you can have your religion/club- it's a free country- no one is telling you not to and no one is telling Joe Spencer he shouldn't be your friend or something. Fucking wear Jelly Shoes and find deeper meaning in The Big Lebowski if you want man. Just don't expect everyone to throw on their bathrobes and GET IT, or expect that people will not make snap judgments and snarky comments on your Religion (fan club.) People take issue with other people's Fan Clubs (religions) all the time. You "Dudes" should be prepared for internet snark, if your faith is strong (relaxed) enough you'll weather the storm.

As a side note, it is entirely possible to get a joke and not find it amusing. Just as it is entirely possible for someone to get the joke- think it's kind of funny- and still find the whole thing completely absurd, that's the ship I'm currently sailing in (see also Flying Spaghetti Monster.)

Everyone who doesn't get your joke, or makes a snarky comment is not automatically an Eagle loving, skinny jeans wearing, Hipster. (you should really tone down the hipster stereo typing... it seems to go against the tenants of "Fuck it" and "just take it easy".)

Anyway, I'm a fan of The Big Lebowski. I went to the festival, drank white russians, quoted the movie with the other nerds, bowled and had a great time. I guess what I'm saying is...Can we just hug it out, and end this? (this olive branch also goes to you to Joe Spencer.)

If you're ever in San Diego,CA- mayhaps we can go bowling...first rounds on me... I hope they take checks.

Posted by: PURPLE_DRANK profile link  in reply to  Oliver Benjamin's comment at 08/13/09 1:18 PM  | Reply
Score = 4 Vote up Vote down

Oh shit, this actually IS my boyfriend.

Posted by: Cromwell's Head profile link at 08/12/09 8:07 PM  | Reply
Score = 8 Vote up Vote down

I didn't shill for Volkswagen. Look, just because something is featured in a commercial doesn't make it evil. They wanted to feature Dudeism in a series of shorts that celebrated the power of cinema. What's wrong with that?

In Los Angeles we used to have Los Angeles Times ads run before movies where they'd discuss lesser-known aspects of the movie industry. They were interesting, too. Wouldn't you rather watch me make a fool of myself before a movie than an actual car ad?

There are more: http://creativity-online.com/work/volkswagen-see-film-differently-dudeism/16768

Posted by: Oliver Benjamin at 08/12/09 8:32 PM  | Reply
Score = -6 Vote up Vote down

What internet patrol? My friend Joe told me that you guys were writing about me so I came to see what it was all about.

Why is everyone here so jaded? You hipsters might want to try a little Dudeism. It'll take the edge off a bit.

Anyway, for those who haven't already googled:

http://dudeism.com

As for a lengthy defense: We talk at much greater length about Dudeist philosophy at the site and at the official publication: The Dudespaper. We're about to release a Dudeist version of the Tao Te Ching as well which some of you all sure to not enjoy (sadly): The Tao Dude Ching.

Posted by: Oliver Benjamin at 08/12/09 8:40 PM  | Reply
Score = -4 Vote up Vote down

You are making my brain hemorrhage. Cease and desist.

Posted by: Sedusa profile link  in reply to  Oliver Benjamin's comment at 08/12/09 9:21 PM  | Reply
Score = 3 Vote up Vote down

This is all actually pretty amazing, because just last week I founded Intolerable Crueltyism.

Posted by: MarkyBob profile link  in reply to  Oliver Benjamin's comment at 08/12/09 9:27 PM  | Reply
Score = 22 Vote up Vote down

a.k.a. Masseychism.

Posted by: Oliver Benjamin  in reply to  MarkyBob's comment at 08/19/09 4:31 AM  | Reply
Score = 0 Vote up Vote down

Oliver, Oliver. We Gummerz are a loving, friendly, tolerant people. We're just snarky. If you want to wear your robe and jellies, that's your Dude-given right. Who are we to judge?
Just don't come knocking on the door of my local bowling alley (or spamming in the comments of my favorite website [just kidding {OR AM I???}]) with tracts, ok...
All smiles.

Posted by: Becca profile link  in reply to  Oliver Benjamin's comment at 08/12/09 11:07 PM  | Reply
Score = 12 Vote up Vote down

Hold on, Gabe. If this was a cute Japanese girl who was shitting herself with joy over The Big Lebowski, wouldn't she be "living the dream we didn't even know we had?" Why didn't we jump all over that Harry Potter chick for the seriousness with which she took her mission as part of a fan club? She seemed a lot more loony than this guy does, and yet you found inspiration in her. (I think. You've pretty much perfected the art of blog irony. Gold star!)

Posted by: strangely_brown at 08/12/09 9:12 PM  | Reply
Score = 4 Vote up Vote down

There is one key difference here: she was an adolescent and he's an adult.

Posted by: Jesseca! profile link  in reply to  strangely_brown's comment at 08/13/09 11:18 PM  | Reply
Score = 3 Vote up Vote down

Man, I never realized that the comment board is filled to the brim with assholes.

Say what you will about 'Dudeism', at least it's an ethos.

Posted by: Sebastian Paper at 08/12/09 9:23 PM  | Reply
Score = 0 Vote up Vote down

I'm not upset. I'm perfectly calm. i only think it's worthwhile to explain dudeism to those who don't actually know what it is. perhaps my toe did slip over the line. sorry.

Posted by: Oliver Benjamin at 08/12/09 10:09 PM  | Reply
Score = 2 Vote up Vote down

You know what? I may not necessarily see things the same way you do, but it all sounds pretty legitimate, and you seem like a really kind and lovely individual. Everybody needs to maybe calm down. If we were all openly attacking a follower of a religion we were more familiar with, this would be Hate Crime City.

Posted by: chickchick profile link  in reply to  Oliver Benjamin's comment at 08/12/09 11:05 PM  | Reply
Score = 4 Vote up Vote down

Huh? Like half of Lindsay's posts (never forget!) were about Christian shenanigans, and those threads were often brutal, and I'm pretty sure we're all familiar with Christianity. I don't think those were Hate Crime City.

Posted by: chittychiity bang bang  in reply to  chickchick's comment at 08/13/09 12:00 PM  | Reply
Score = 4 Vote up Vote down

For someone who writes about movies and supposedly thinks(?) about movies all day, the whole freshman-comp "it's just a movie" line seems like a bit of a cop-out, Gabe.

Fuck, the Bible is "just a book."

Posted by: J at 08/12/09 10:09 PM  | Reply
Score = -6 Vote up Vote down

Except that the Bible (or Tanakh, Qu'ran, whatever) purports to be a religious text and The Big Lebowski purports to be a work of fiction. If you think they're the same because you think they're both works of fiction, you need to bring in extratextual evidence to show that for the Bible (etc) because it purports to be true. The Big Lebowski is up-front about the fact that it is fictional and not a religion. It doesn't mean you can't find great meaning in it (and base a philosophy around it, even), but pretending it is the basis for a "religion" just doesn't work.

Posted by: freshman comp  in reply to  J's comment at 08/13/09 9:48 AM  | Reply
Score = 3 Vote up Vote down

I agree with you, Freshmancomp, and I think that Gabe's argument would be more clear and valid if he wrote what you just did -- instead of trying to belittle the medium itself, as if an interest in art* or "cultural documents" is somehow a childish preoccupation**.

*I'm not calling the Big Lebowski, specifically, art. But you get the idea. The whole, "You can buy it on DVD. You are an adult" thing rubs me the wrong way. You can buy Hamlet on DVD. Or you can download the Bible, or the Qu'ran to your iphone. That doesn't somehow make it less valuable, or less worthy of scrutiny. Your argument, freshmancomp, about what a document "purports to be" makes much more sense to me.

**Again, this is funny because Gabe's living is basically built on writing detailed interpretations of movies like "August Rush" and "The Lake House"

Lastly, freshmancomp, to address your own argument: isn't belief the only thing that really predicates a religion? If millions of people started worshipping/deifying Holden Caufield - how does that somehow make the religion, itself, invalid as a belief system? It may be stupid, or delusional, or even glaringly "false," -- but it's still a "religion." I think the assumption that your argument makes is that religion, somehow, is isolated from culture - when, in fact, it's the opposite: religion is a product of human beings and the rituals and rites they perform. Some religions, like Buddhism, don't even address theological certainties. And, yes, semantics come into play here: we tend to call smaller and newer belief systems "cults" -- and larger, more older ones "religions" -- and ancient, extinct ones we call "mythologies." So maybe the issue here is partly semantic; if this guy called his Lebowskism a "cult," would we really object? And, yes, I realize that I just contradicted myself. Oh well - I worried it out by writing about it, thanks freshman comp!

Posted by: J  in reply to  freshman comp's comment at 08/13/09 1:47 PM  | Reply
Score = 0 Vote up Vote down

No prob, comment friend! Hope to see you and Shaggy 2 Dope at the Gathering next year. And no, I don't think religion is reducible to either sincerely-held belief or social structue and rituals; both are necessary, but neither is sufficient. I'm not sure what that has to do with a discussion of source texts, though. And even if we did reduce religion to either of those things, you can still draw a distinction between beliefs/rituals ordered around something that claims to be a source of that ordering (possibly wrong) and those ordered around something that makes no such claim (definitely wrong).

Posted by: freshman comp  in reply to  J's comment at 08/13/09 3:55 PM  | Reply
Score = 0 Vote up Vote down

Yes. Yes, exactly. The bible IS just a book.

Posted by: lemonne profile link  in reply to  J's comment at 08/13/09 12:52 PM  | Reply
Score = 3 Vote up Vote down

Say what you will about the tenets of Dudeism...at least it's an ethos!

Posted by: vicarhelmet profile link at 08/12/09 10:31 PM  | Reply
Score = 3 Vote up Vote down

Dammit, too slow. Sorry, Sebastian Paper. (Although I object to the idea that Vgum commenters are assholes. Relax, Sebastian Paper!)

Posted by: vicarhelmet profile link  in reply to  vicarhelmet's comment at 08/12/09 10:43 PM  | Reply
Score = 2 Vote up Vote down

I didn't shill for Volkswagen. Look, just because something is featured in a commercial doesn't make it evil. They wanted to feature Dudeism in a series of shorts that celebrated the power of cinema. What's wrong with that?

I don't take issue with your bathrobe and your goof troop but with VW saying, "Look, people do nutsy, passionate things because of movies, and that's a great thing. Special delivery: You've got a different way to see cinema. We support independent film. You're welcome."

What? Wolksvagen saying it supports "independent cinema" is, like, really cool of them, but getting into what constitutes independent cinema (much less how VW is contributing to it by point out people doing nutsy, passionate things in response to particular movies) is a sticky bucket of syrup in itself.

Posted by: whoawhoawhoa profile link at 08/12/09 11:20 PM  | Reply
Score = 3 Vote up Vote down

say what you will about the tenants of [dudeism], dude, but at least it's an ethos!

Posted by: A Face With A View at 08/13/09 12:10 AM  | Reply
Score = -2 Vote up Vote down

I've never watched The Big Lebowski mostly because it's the favorite movie one of my house mates. And that pretty much tells me that I should think it's unbearable.

Also, relax Oliver Benjamin. You don't get to be offended by people telling you that our religion that you made up is fake and tell everyone else that theirs is fake. That's what we call "hypocrisy".

Posted by: .bryan. profile link at 08/13/09 12:18 AM  | Reply
Score = 2 Vote up Vote down

Let's paint, exercise, and take this thread really seriously.

Posted by: Mackinley6 profile link at 08/13/09 1:03 AM  | Reply
Score = 12 Vote up Vote down

When did I say other religions were fake? I must be on a strict drug regimen because I don't see that anywhere on this page.

I think some of you folks aren't getting what is "satirical" about Dudeism. It's not mocking other religions. I do have some gripes with their dogmas but that's not germane to the issue at hand. As I mentioned in the video I studied lots of them and found aspects of each profound and illuminating. Pointing out that they worship fictitious characters is no swipe against them, at least not in my book.

What is satirical about Dudeism is that unlike other religions (except Taoism and Zen) it finds nothing sacred and so happily has fun with religious traditional formalism. It's playful and partially absurd.

Nevertheless, I was obliged to point out the fact that everyone was criticizing Dudeism without having the faintest clue what it was all about. I posted the link to the site so that you could have a look, not to spam.

No harm taken, fellas. Just doing my job.

Posted by: Oliver Benjamin at 08/13/09 1:35 AM  | Reply
Score = -1 Vote up Vote down

dude, you're being very un-dude
nothing is fucked here..

Posted by: tizzdogg  in reply to  Oliver Benjamin's comment at 08/13/09 9:44 AM  | Reply
Score = 4 Vote up Vote down

Nothing is fucked here dude, nothing is fucked.

Posted by: the dude profile link  in reply to  Oliver Benjamin's comment at 08/13/09 10:13 AM  | Reply
Score = 4 Vote up Vote down

When I was young we went to the church of Caddyshack dagnabbit.

By going to church I mean watched repeatedly while stoned.

Posted by: Joe at 08/13/09 2:28 AM  | Reply
Score = 0 Vote up Vote down

We both could be getting some joy here if you had listened to me about the 'Bakerism', bro

Posted by: Beau Bridges at 08/13/09 9:23 AM  | Reply
Score = 0 Vote up Vote down

It's funny that the Big Lebowski might be seen as the "message for our time and place." Isn't that what the cowboy narrator guy said about the Dude, that he was the perfect man for his time and place? I.e., LA in the early 90's? And, therefore, pretty irrelevant in the internet-, and let alone post-you-know-what, age?

Posted by: tps12 at 08/13/09 10:13 AM  | Reply
Score = -1 Vote up Vote down

Ahhh I just woke up why is everyone yelling!?

Posted by: tibmalian profile link at 08/13/09 10:29 AM  | Reply
Score = 2 Vote up Vote down

Also I am a follower of an heretical offshoot sect known as Dell-Dudeism.

Posted by: tps12 at 08/13/09 10:45 AM  | Reply
Score = 0 Vote up Vote down

The real question is: why aren't we talking about this Ally McBeal convention?

I want to go to there

Posted by: TheRevengeOfJeffGoldblum profile link at 08/13/09 12:37 PM  | Reply
Score = 3 Vote up Vote down

Most religious scholars and even many ardent followers of Christianity (c.f. the Vatican cardinal in Bill Maher's Religulous and followers of Unitarian Universalism) contend that the Bible is pure allegory. The Yogic tradition of Hinduism maintains the same. So does the Zen tradition vis a vis Buddhism. And most reform Jews don't take a word of the Torah literally.

As Joseph Campbell pointed out, fiction is very often truer than "truth."

Posted by: Oliver Benjamin at 08/13/09 4:02 PM  | Reply
Score = -2 Vote up Vote down

I dig your style Purple Drank. But I'm still confused why everyone thinks I'm angry.

I'm perfectly happy with people criticizing anything and everything. But that doesn't mean people shouldn't offer up defenses if they've got one.

You'll notice that in the movie, the Dude does his fair share of sticking up for himself when confronted with unchecked aggression. But it never gets to him.

And also, why am I not allowed to respond to internet snark with a little snark of my own? I mean, really, this article totally blows. That's just my opinion, man, and you all may disagree, but old Gabe here has nothing to say except "me no like." What's your fucking point, Walter? Real reactionary. I've seen better English composition on the walls of a Bangkok prison.

And come on, my pal Joe calling you "fuck nuts" is over the line? Really? Have you read some of the other stuff folks have written here?

And my making a joke that you're all hipsters is somehow bad form? Jeez. I guess it's time for me to stay out of Malibu. Or Silverlake, as the case may be.

Posted by: Oliver Benjamin at 08/13/09 6:02 PM  | Reply
Score = -1 Vote up Vote down

Look, man, I think people think that you are angry because you are seeking out confrontation, not being faced with it. You made a video espousing your beliefs, which was sponsored by a giant corporation and thus should have made you reasonably aware that a lot of people would see it (as compared to something you placed on YouTube). You then heard that someone did not like the video and made a point to seek those people out and repeatedly argue with them. I suppose this would be like if the Dude filmed an infomercial on his rug, and then he heard someone didn't like his rug, and he made a point of following them around to try to convince them that if they just knew more about the rug, they'd agree with him. That'd be a very different film, though, and a very different Dude. There's a difference between the way the Dude reacted to trespass, assault, and theft and the way he reacted to the Big Lebowski criticizing his lifestyle.

Posted by: Mainly-Anon  in reply to  Oliver Benjamin's comment at 08/14/09 8:55 AM  | Reply
Score = 1 Vote up Vote down

For clarity's sake: I had something to do with this mini-doc/ad/film-ident.

"VW supports independent cinema" -- It's slightly confusing, I know. Here in the UK, Independent Cinema translates to: Independent Movie Theatres, not Independent Films.

I.e., places not owned by Odeon or AMC, et al. Generally, the one-screen, old cinemas that are having a tough time staying afloat these days.

VW is helping to keep many of them up and running. These theatres often screen mainstream films, sometimes not, but Seeing Film Differently means celebrating these theatres, as well as taking a different look at films.

I think there's value in Dudeism and I agree that the world probably would be a better place if we all had a little more Dude in our lives. But if you've got a very strict idea of what a religion could, this message may come off as silly.

Of course there is humour in the video and there's a risk that this will cloud any deeper meaning for some people. But I think the least we can hope for is that people relate because we've all at some point been deeply moved by a film. Personally, I think Oliver Benjamin comes of as educated, intelligent and funny.

So, does VW's involvement spoil the message? That's like your opinion, man. Maybe you'll think a little better or worse about VW after this, but it seems to me that their hearts were in the right place on this project. Sometimes a corporation can do good.

Agree or disagree, I think it all depends on how jaded you are.


Posted by: Semi-Anon at 08/14/09 5:38 AM  | Reply
Score = 0 Vote up Vote down

Thanks, that is a really useful clarification. The VW sponsorship/indie cinema thing didn't concern me that much, but hopefully that resolves it for other people.

Posted by: Mainly-Anon  in reply to  Semi-Anon's comment at 08/14/09 9:02 AM  | Reply
Score = 1 Vote up Vote down

I think all this criticism of this ad is very un-dude.

The dude is not an uptight ultra-lefty, anarchist, anti-capitalist. He just didn't give a shit about a lot of things.

And as for those who think the ad exploits Dude and Dudeism, I'd say relax man. The Dude has nothing against being exploited. Maude "exploited" him when she collected his seed so she could get pregnant. The only thing that bothered him was the possiblity that he would have
to be responsible for the child. But once she calmed that fear, he was perfectly okay.

Posted by: Bill Bittner at 08/14/09 1:03 PM  | Reply
Score = 0 Vote up Vote down

I hope that helps as well, thanks Semi-anon.

However, if commentators are going to continue to maintain that they can say whatever they want about Dudeism and that's okay, while if someone from Dudeism (e.g. me) comes in and shares their point of view with well reasoned, thought-out and often goofy replies, then that's somehow stepping over the line -- well then, then they might want to grow a pair of testicles (special ladies too). These are the rules. They affects all of us. Our basic freedoms.

Also, you all might want to watch the movie again. You'll notice that just because the Dude excelled at taking it easy doesn't mean he wasn't fond of bickering with his pals when they were full of crap.

In fact I'm quite enjoying this discussion. Parts, anyway. I'm still not the slightest bit angry. Maybe I need to use more emoticons.

Anyway, to parahrpase the Dude: I love you guys, but sooner or later you're going to have to face the fact that some of you are goddamn morons.

Posted by: Oliver Benjamin at 08/14/09 1:16 PM  | Reply
Score = -1 Vote up Vote down

This article is not an article. Just because you can type words does not make you a writer. What a waste :(

Posted by: FreeParty at 08/14/09 6:34 PM  | Reply
Score = -2 Vote up Vote down

I admit the Big Lebowski is my favourite movie, but this all seems kind of tongue in cheek.

This guy isn't the worst by any stretch of the imagination.

Posted by: Steve Sanders profile link at 08/14/09 11:37 PM  | Reply
Score = 0 Vote up Vote down

Why doesn't he worship "The Jesus"?

Posted by: zach profile link at 08/15/09 3:13 PM  | Reply
Score = 1 Vote up Vote down

no one fucks with the jesus

Posted by: kurt russell profile link  in reply to  zach's comment at 08/16/09 4:53 PM  | Reply
Score = 1 Vote up Vote down

fuck it dude lets go bowling

Posted by: kurt russell profile link at 08/16/09 4:50 PM  | Reply
Score = 1 Vote up Vote down

But the dude rarely takes it easy...Walter is mostly calm, The Dude is mostly worked up.

Get a job, sir.

Posted by: Ab at 08/19/09 4:36 PM  | Reply
Score = 0 Vote up Vote down

"Walter is mostly calm" Waving the fucking gun around? Did we watch the same movie, Ab?

Posted by: Irish Monk at 08/25/09 10:34 AM  | Reply
Score = 0 Vote up Vote down

Leave a comment


Staff

  • Founder/Editor-In-Chief: Scott Lapatine
  • Senior Editor: Gabe Delahaye
  • Executive Editor: Amrit Singh

Info

Contact

You Can Make It Up logo
Gabe loves fan fiction. You Can Make It Up features his own personal alternate adventures starring some of our favorite characters.

You Can Make It Up: Rip Torn Gambles On The Puppy Bowl

Rip Torn's eyes would barely open and his face was a ravaged, haggard, stubbly mess. His chapped lips stuck together, and the pavement had left a red, mottled impression against his cheek. He looked around blearily, barely able to focus...

MORE »

The Hunt For The Worst Movie Of All Time logo
After watching Death Sentence, a terrible movie starring Kevin Bacon as a father in search of vigilante justice directed by Saw's James Wan, Gabe embarked on The Hunt For The Worst Movie of All Time. This is his sad journey.

The Hunt For The Worst Movie Of All Time: Serendipity

You know, the truth is, I actually like romantic comedies. I am man enough to admit that. We all would love to live in a world of love and friendship and gentle laughter. Why not? You think I want it...

MORE »

Monsters' Ball logo
This week's five highest rated comments as voted on by you, the lowest rated comment as voted on by you, and the editor's choice.

Monsters' Ball: The Week's Best Comments

In the future, when the ultra-light telepathic super-mecha, derived from the core technology of the Cybertronics "Real Boys" line of love children, are sifting through the ice wastes for any remnants of the long extinct human race that once created...

MORE »

Double Dog logo
Blogging about TV and movies isn't all fun and videogames. Every week, Lindsay or Gabe will be presented with a physical or mental challenge that tests their bravery,patience, and taste.

Double Dog: I Took A TV Bus Tour Alone In A "Just Jack" Tshirt

The Challenge: I had to go on a 3.5 hour bus tour of totally random TV and film locations in New York City. Alone, and wearing a specific ridiculous tshirt. And I had to find someone to take my picture...

MORE »

Videogum Movie Club logo
Let's all go to the movies, and let's all see the same movie, and let's discuss it here.

The Videogum Movie Club: Avatar

"Whoa." --Kebanu Roves It is weird that you can't do things normally in New York sometimes. Like, I'm so sorry that I ate an early dinner before going to see Avatar on Friday night the way that a HUMAN BEING...

MORE »