Videogum Home - inspired by Guilherme Rosa's work in the colors issue of Idea Fixa
May 2, 2008

The Office Is Not Realistic!

thumbnail icon: The Office Is Not Realistic!

My friend Andrew asks a pertinent question about The Office, you guys:

"Is the conceit of the program still that they're being filmed for a documentary? Does that even make sense anymore?"

That is a good question, and I think the answer, as painful as this is going to be to a bunch of you, is no.

The concept for the US version of the show has always been a little lacking. In England, prior to the original Office, there were a handful of actual BBC documentaries (Hotel, Airport) about people in their workplace. Slice of life stuff. Which sets up the humor and reality of The Office beautifully. We didn't have that here, so already the depth of the joke is self-contained in the show. Yes, we recognize the documentarian (or mockumentarian, which I think is offered as an MFA at Tisch now) tropes, but it doesn't have the rooted cultural cachet.

Moreover, by ending the original series after 12 episodes (plus two follow-up specials), it was totally plausible that these people had their lives invaded by a documentary crew for a year, and then went about their average, well-intentioned lives. Here, that's not the case. The documentary crew just won't leave? Who's paying for this? Who's watching this? And why wouldn't the real Michael Scott, or the real Jim and Pam, decide that they no longer wanted to willingly play a part in this excruciating expose of the painful minutae of their lives? In the specials that aired after the original series, David Brent talked about what life was like after being made a fool on national television. But we're expected to believe that three years in, no one mocks Michael Scott openly on the street? The shame of their broadcast romantic exploits hasn't forced Jan into an alcoholic shame spiral?

I don't know how to fix this, The Office. I'm just nervous that you're going to take something wonderful and drive it's face into the dirt.

Still funny though.

Steve Carell is so funny, I'm surprised no one's ever heard of him.

Posted by Gabe at 12:11 PM in
Tags:  |  |  |  |  |  |




-->

7 Comments

It's an interesting question, but I think the "it's for a documentary" conceit of the show was never meant to be a major factor. It's basically a throwaway stylistic device to set up the humor.

Also, as a copy editor, I have to note that "cache" in the third paragraph should be "cachet."

Posted by: emword at 05/02/08 1:08 PM | Reply
Score = 1 Vote up Vote down

I forget about the documentary thing all the time. I only remembered last night when Michael made everyone but Stanley leave and the film crew had to find a covert spot to film them from. Whatever though -- I don't really care about the continuity of it. I like the documentary style and the fact that it means they have no laugh track.

Posted by: jessplease at 05/02/08 2:39 PM | Reply
Score = 0 Vote up Vote down

The first 2-3 seasons were for a potential documentary and now Ryan is making them vlog for Dunder Mifflin Infinity 2.0. That's gotta be it.

Posted by: Chadams at 05/02/08 2:44 PM | Reply
Score = 2 Vote up Vote down

Not to mention a documentary crew wouldn't be invited for things like Pam and Jim's trip to Dwight's beet farm.

Posted by: goathair at 05/02/08 3:30 PM | Reply
Score = 0 Vote up Vote down

This clip was the funniest part of the episode, I think. I was cracking up.

Posted by: adrienne profile link at 05/02/08 3:58 PM | Reply
Score = 0 Vote up Vote down

I hadn't ever thought of the possible conflict here until the recent dinner party episode. I think that was the first episode that the "crew" was invited in somewhere private.

Posted by: Chase Roper at 05/03/08 2:51 AM | Reply
Score = 0 Vote up Vote down

What if the crew has told them all that the show won't air for a few years until they get it all ready. Normally shows shoot ahead of time, although not this many years worth. But, who knows. Meanwhile, this show would be airing in Japan and be the number one comedy. If Michael goes to Japan he'll be treated like a celebrity and sign autographs and get laughed at (which he'll like) and come back and say how NICE the Japanese people are. I believe this could lead to a fun theme party with Hell-o Kitty napkins.

I love Hell-o Kitty.

Posted by: Jessica Rae at 05/25/08 3:30 PM | Reply
Score = 0 Vote up Vote down

Leave a comment


 

Write Us

tips@videogum.com

Search




Sort by:date relevance

Information

  • Contact:
  • About
  • Press
  • Advertising
  • Videogum RSS Videogum RSS XML Icon

Staff

Founder/Editor-In-Chief
Scott Lapatine
Senior Editors
Gabe Delahaye
Lindsay Robertson
Executive Editor
Amrit Singh
Technology & Operations
Jim Jazwiecki
Angela Williams

Facebook logo

All Videogum Posts

Logo by Guilherme Rosa

The following are sponsored posts for which we made videos that came out really funny.

[Sponsored] Fujifilm Z Spot Miami Contest

We once again interrupt Videogum's usual posting schedule of viral fart videos and behind-the-scenes Jennie Garth news in order to display our second post that is an actual advertisement. Fuji won't quit with the contests. In case you are worried...

MORE »

The Hunt For The Worst Movie Of All Time logo
After watching Death Sentence, a terrible movie starring Kevin Bacon as a father in search of vigilante justice directed by Saw's James Wan, Gabe embarked on The Hunt For The Worst Movie of All Time. This is his sad journey.

The Hunt For The Worst Movie Of All Time: Round Two Late Additions

I'm coming to realize that I've set for myself an impossible task. I'm like Don Quixote facing off against the windmills, except that the windmills are really difficult to watch, and often the windmills have Bruce Willis or Dakota Fanning...

MORE »

Double Dog logo
Blogging about TV and movies isn't all fun and videogames. Every week, Lindsay or Gabe will be presented with a physical or mental challenge that tests their bravery, patience, and taste.

Double Dog: My First And Last Survivor Audition Tape

The Challenge: Despite being averse to cameras, teamwork, exotic foods, travel, haircuts, and physical exertion, I have to submit an audition tape to Survivor. The Result: As with the Saw marathon challenge, once again I find myself rocking back and...

MORE »

Friday Fight logo
Even though Lindsay and Gabe are friends, they very rarely agree on anything. Every day, they have a fight about something. On Fridays, we publish one.

Friday Fight: Who Is Worse For The Country Than Sarah Palin?

Gabe: who is worse for the country Gabe: sarah palin or serena van der woodsen? Lindsay: Well definitely Palin. Gabe: no, i mean as president Gabe: just kidding Gabe: a serena van der woodsen presidency Gabe: though Gabe: would be...

MORE »

You Can Make It Up logo
Gabe loves fan fiction. You Can Make It Up features his own personal alternate adventures starring some of our favorite characters.

You Can Make It Up: Gossip Girl, The Hills, And The New 90210 Have Tea At The Plaza Hotel

Violin music gently filled the tastefully appointed Tea Room at the Plaza Hotel. Blair Waldorf and Serena Van Der Woodsen sat at a table near the back, along with Nate Archibald, Chuck Bass, and Dan Humphrey. Accompanying them were Heidi...

MORE »