Videogum Home - designed by Guilherme Rosa

 

June 17, 2009

Who Should Play Larry In The Three Stooges Movie?

thumbnail icon: Who Should Play Larry In The Three Stooges Movie?

Oh no! Terrible news! According to Variety, Sean Penn is dropping out of the Farrelly brothers Three Stooges movie. Obviously, this completely destroys the PERFECT casting this movie already had of Sean Penn, Benicio Del Toro, and Jim Carrey. All three together on screen at long last? It was too good to be true! This movie was going to be the Heat of completely unnecessary comedic tributes to an antiquated slapstick comedy troupe for four-year-olds.

It's almost silly to talk about replacing Sean Penn as Larry, since he's such an irreplaceable comedic actor who is so funny and comedic and was always from the very beginning a totally perfect pick for the role*, but we simply have GOT TO have this Three Stooges movie. America will not rest until it sees the Farrelly brothers Three Stooges movie. So who could do it? (Remember: they will be joining Benicio Del Toro and Jim Carrey, so obviously they have to be perfect, since this cast is still 2/3 PERFECT.)

Bobb'e J Thompson

Sure, he is just a child. And he is black. But he has more comedic chops than BENICIO DEL TORO. Besides, this kid's star is on the rise, so maybe he could somehow make this movie that no one wants be a movie that someone wants.

Tony Hawk

Cowabunga dude! Tony Hawk would bring what's been missing from this project all along: the completely-false-but-somehow-it-always-seems-to-still-work "cool factor." Dude is like 55 years old but everyone pretends like he's a wayward high school junior who just wants to thrash. And that's fresh!

Alicia Silverstone

She is available.

A Rotisserie Chicken

Succulent. Plump. Delicious. A rotisserie chicken could take a lot of hammers to the face and keep on working. And by working I mean sitting there. And by sitting there I mean sitting there in my stomach. Yum!

Anyone else? Jada Pinkett Smith, probably. Anyone else?

*Sarcasm.

Posted by Gabe at 9:30 AM in
Tags:  |  |  |  |




42 Comments

You got possibly the least flattering picture of Silverstone EVER.


But....how about Ken Jeong?

Posted by: CarolineA profile link at 06/17/09 9:43 AM  | Reply
Score = 3 Vote up Vote down

Is Nicolas Cage not free? That asshole is in everything.

Posted by: Funtastik profile link at 06/17/09 9:44 AM  | Reply
Score = 30 Vote up Vote down

He's busy selling castles.

Posted by: E-Swag profile link  in reply to  Funtastik's comment at 06/17/09 1:37 PM  | Reply
Score = 9 Vote up Vote down

Samuel Jackson, In 1 out of 10 movies.

Posted by: I PEE GOLD profile link  in reply to  Funtastik's comment at 06/17/09 2:06 PM  | Reply
Score = 8 Vote up Vote down

It's a tough call between Ms. Silverstone and the chicken, but I'm going with the chicken. He's a seasoned pro.

Posted by: benjamin profile link at 06/17/09 9:49 AM  | Reply
Score = 101 Vote up Vote down

I wish I could give this more up votes, Lots Of Love

Posted by: radioactive rabbit profile link  in reply to  benjamin's comment at 06/17/09 6:40 PM  | Reply
Score = 2 Vote up Vote down

A Wahlberg?

Posted by: DanBlurns profile link at 06/17/09 9:50 AM  | Reply
Score = 7 Vote up Vote down

Johnny 5. I mean, he'd need a wig, but otherwise perfect.

Posted by: Friendly Giant profile link at 06/17/09 9:55 AM  | Reply
Score = 0 Vote up Vote down

What's Jonathan Lipnicki up to? He might be perfect!

Posted by: CarolineA profile link at 06/17/09 9:57 AM  | Reply
Score = 5 Vote up Vote down

How about Da Cake Eatur?

Posted by: booferama profile link at 06/17/09 10:01 AM  | Reply
Score = 13 Vote up Vote down

Just read the first sentence. Done. Laughed my ass off. Thank you.

Posted by: Zzyzx profile link at 06/17/09 10:15 AM  | Reply
Score = -1 Vote up Vote down

Oh no! did it for you? Congrats Gabe, I think you just got to that stage where now you can pretty much write anything and people will send you Lots of Love no matter what, Jay Leno style.

Posted by: Ugah profile link  in reply to  Zzyzx's comment at 06/17/09 10:28 AM  | Reply
Score = 16 Vote up Vote down

Gwyneth Paltrow? We all know she's hilarious and she'll bring out the shiny legs.

Posted by: Tiffany at 06/17/09 10:23 AM  | Reply
Score = 11 Vote up Vote down

Oh people this is so obvious I can't believe none of you have got it yet. The film-makers should just dig up Larry's corpse and use that. I mean it's no worse an idea than making this film.

Posted by: annoyingmouse profile link at 06/17/09 10:24 AM  | Reply
Score = 5 Vote up Vote down

George W. Bush?

Posted by: tiffanybor profile link at 06/17/09 10:28 AM  | Reply
Score = -1 Vote up Vote down

Just rewatched the trailer for TipToes and was inspired to nominate Gary Oldman, in the role of a lifetime. As his TipToes self, of course.

Posted by: RichGuy profile link at 06/17/09 10:34 AM  | Reply
Score = 7 Vote up Vote down

Robert Pattinson.

Posted by: Carrie profile link at 06/17/09 10:37 AM  | Reply
Score = 9 Vote up Vote down

Oh, man, without Sean Penn you have to recast the entire movie.

I'd cast Owen Wilson, Ben Stiller, and Will Farrell. Does it matter who plays what with that much comedic brilliance on display?

Or we can just have Eddie Murphy play all 3. Now THAT'S box office gold!

Posted by: Ken at 06/17/09 10:37 AM  | Reply
Score = 18 Vote up Vote down

I propose we wipe the whole cast and start over with Bobbe J Thompson. Actually we need an all black three stooges. Breakin' barriers! So, we got Bobbe J -maybe as a midget, cos I want him to be, like, 30. Martin Lawrence seems perfect though he'll obviously play the one thats a little smarter and hits everyone over the head (I've never seen the show can you tell?). Oh and this is out of left field but Sinbad? I think he's still got it. So, anyone else got picks?

Posted by: Ben (waiting for the perfect GIF) profile link at 06/17/09 10:39 AM  | Reply
Score = 6 Vote up Vote down

Rob Thomas

Posted by: Tooom profile link at 06/17/09 10:42 AM  | Reply
Score = 4 Vote up Vote down

who the fucks rob thomas?

Posted by: Panda Snare profile link  in reply to  Tooom's comment at 06/17/09 10:53 AM  | Reply
Score = 0 Vote up Vote down

You are the luckiest man alive.

Posted by: LinerNotesDanny profile link  in reply to  Panda Snare's comment at 06/17/09 11:13 AM  | Reply
Score = 35 Vote up Vote down

Sinbad

Posted by: zach  in reply to  Tooom's comment at 06/17/09 12:27 PM  | Reply
Score = 4 Vote up Vote down

da castins for dis moobie are nots good! da gabe and lindsaysj are sooo right! dis makes mees feels betterj aboats myself! lololololol!

Posted by: fatmanj profile link at 06/17/09 11:17 AM  | Reply
Score = -25 Vote up Vote down

I'm sorry, that position's been filled.

Posted by: LinerNotesDanny profile link  in reply to  fatmanj's comment at 06/17/09 11:23 AM  | Reply
Score = 43 Vote up Vote down

Somebody's gay dad?

Posted by: simonsays profile link at 06/17/09 11:48 AM  | Reply
Score = 5 Vote up Vote down

and by somebody's gay dad I mean the Jonas Brothers...

Posted by: simonsays profile link  in reply to  simonsays's comment at 06/17/09 11:51 AM  | Reply
Score = 3 Vote up Vote down

Marlon Brando.

Posted by: goathair at 06/17/09 11:55 AM  | Reply
Score = 0 Vote up Vote down

Zach Galifianakis

Posted by: Niamh profile link at 06/17/09 12:16 PM  | Reply
Score = 4 Vote up Vote down

The two "Slumdog" kids, but with one of them sitting on the other's shoulders and wearing a trenchcoat.

Posted by: MarkyBob profile link at 06/17/09 12:18 PM  | Reply
Score = 28 Vote up Vote down

Gabe, I think your footnotes are getting a bit out of hand. Intervention!

Posted by: PJH at 06/17/09 12:56 PM  | Reply
Score = 4 Vote up Vote down

Seth Macfarlane?! Then he can try to bring down the Oscars alongside his efforts to bring down the Emmys.

Posted by: josh at 06/17/09 1:03 PM  | Reply
Score = 1 Vote up Vote down

Pleeeease hire Alicia Silverstone and call it Three Stooges: Excess Baggage 2!

Posted by: Shane2012 profile link at 06/17/09 1:48 PM  | Reply
Score = 3 Vote up Vote down

David Paymer would've been good 15 years ago...he's a dead ringer and needs some RESPECT!

http://www.imdb.com/name/nm0001601/

Posted by: Hooobags at 06/17/09 1:52 PM  | Reply
Score = 0 Vote up Vote down

missing the point, bro

Posted by: Lux profile link  in reply to  Hooobags's comment at 06/17/09 2:04 PM  | Reply
Score = 4 Vote up Vote down

Yeah, Hoobag. You missing the point. The point is to to be snarky and prejudice.

Seriously, I know Videogum has always been a little too-cool-for-school and complainy, but lately Gabe is starting to go full (Andy) Rooney.

I'm not sure why we are suppose to be against this casting. Del Toro was pretty awesomely funny in "Fear and Loathing". Sean Penn was great as Spicolli. Sure, maybe they're not funny in a have-my-own-blog kind of way, but they're accomplished actors. I think they can handle the task of being hit on the head by a frying pan. I'm sure if we had all heard Tom Cruise was going to be in a comedy with Ben Stiller, Gabe would have done the same bit on who would be a better choice. SPOILER: The last suggestion is an inanimate object.

You were wrong about Fallon. You'll be wrong about this.

P.S. I won't defend Jim Carrey though

Posted by: Sebastian Paper  in reply to  Lux's comment at 06/17/09 3:01 PM  | Reply
Score = -4 Vote up Vote down

I APOLOGIZE "hooooooobags" because now everyone here thinks your a douchenozzle for taking this seriously.

Posted by: An American Patriot profile link  in reply to  Hooobags's comment at 06/17/09 3:39 PM  | Reply
Score = -1 Vote up Vote down

You guys we should all support casting Tommy Wiseau. He needs to get on funding for a new movie STAT.

Posted by: radioactive rabbit profile link at 06/17/09 6:44 PM  | Reply
Score = 5 Vote up Vote down

The chicken part made me cry tears of laughter. If the chicken doesn't get the role there is no justice in the world.

Posted by: kate profile link at 06/17/09 9:29 PM  | Reply
Score = -1 Vote up Vote down

They should definitely pick Stephen Wright (the guy on the couch - Half Baked) He'd nail that role..... or maybe Jon Lovitz with a wig! Yeaaah..... that's the ticket!

Posted by: Steve Fuentes at 06/25/09 7:44 PM  | Reply
Score = 0 Vote up Vote down

They should definitely pick Stephen Wright (the guy on the couch - Half Baked) He'd nail that role..... or maybe Jon Lovitz with a wig! Yeaaah..... that's the ticket!

Posted by: Steve Fuentes at 06/25/09 7:45 PM  | Reply
Score = 0 Vote up Vote down

They should definitely pick Stephen Wright (the guy on the couch - Half Baked) He'd nail that role..... or maybe Jon Lovitz with a wig! Yeaaah..... that's the ticket!

Posted by: Steve Fuentes at 06/25/09 7:45 PM  | Reply
Score = 0 Vote up Vote down

Leave a comment


Staff

  • Founder/Editor-In-Chief: Scott Lapatine
  • Senior Editor: Gabe Delahaye
  • Executive Editor: Amrit Singh

Info

Contact

You Can Make It Up logo
Gabe loves fan fiction. You Can Make It Up features his own personal alternate adventures starring some of our favorite characters.

You Can Make It Up: People Tell Carrie Prejean What An Asshole She Is

Carrie Prejean turned the video camera off, put on some clothes, and stepped out of her house. It was a beautiful day outside. The air smelled like apples, and the late morning light hit the world in just such a...

MORE »

The Hunt For The Worst Movie Of All Time logo
After watching Death Sentence, a terrible movie starring Kevin Bacon as a father in search of vigilante justice directed by Saw's James Wan, Gabe embarked on The Hunt For The Worst Movie of All Time. This is his sad journey.

The Hunt For The Worst Movie Of All Time: In The Land Of The Women

If you are a sassy and sarcastic young man in an American sitcom who represents the sitcom writer's desire that a nerdy Jewish teenager can somehow be the desirable romantic hero in this world, then eventually you will get a...

MORE »

Monsters' Ball logo
This week's five highest rated comments as voted on by you, the lowest rated comment as voted on by you, and the editor's choice.

Monsters' Ball: The Week's Best Comments

I shouldn't even be here right now. I SHOULD BE GETTING INTO MY COSTUME! If I don't hurry, my facepaint won't be dry before I get to the MOONVIE theater, and everyone will be like "hahah, you look like you're...

MORE »

Double Dog logo
Blogging about TV and movies isn't all fun and videogames. Every week, Lindsay or Gabe will be presented with a physical or mental challenge that tests their bravery,patience, and taste.

Double Dog: I Took A TV Bus Tour Alone In A "Just Jack" Tshirt

The Challenge: I had to go on a 3.5 hour bus tour of totally random TV and film locations in New York City. Alone, and wearing a specific ridiculous tshirt. And I had to find someone to take my picture...

MORE »

Videogum Movie Club logo
Let's all go to the movies, and let's all see the same movie, and let's discuss it here.

The Videogum Movie Club: 2012

Uh. OK. Well, first let's address what this movie did well, like the disappointed parents we are (or at least that I am), recognizing that the negative feedback won't be useful or constructive if it isn't preceded by something positive....

MORE »