Videogum Home - designed by Guilherme Rosa

 

March 25, 2009

Would It Be Possible To Come Up With A Weirder Cast For The Three Stooges?

thumbnail icon: Would It Be Possible To Come Up With A Weirder Cast For The Three Stooges?

The cast has been announced for the Farrelly Brothers' completely unnecessary (but very timely?) Three Stooges movie, and it is ridiculous. From Variety:

Studio has set Sean Penn to play Larry, and negotiations are underway with Jim Carrey to play Curly, with the actor already making plans to gain 40 pounds to approximate the physical dimensions of Jerome "Curly" Howard.

The studio is zeroing in on Benicio Del Toro to play Moe.

Wait, whuuuuuuuuut? Hurry up, studio. Zero in! You don't want the only person in the world who could play Moe to drop out of the project. Wait, what did I say? Not the only person, I meant the last person. Better. Why does this movie even exist? I know that Hollywood is out of ideas or whatever, but this doesn't even seem like a rehashed idea. This seems like confusion over how ideas even work in the first place.

It's basically impossible to come up with a weirder, less likely cast for this movie. But I have tried. After the jump, four slightly more improbable--but only slightly--casts for the Farrelly Brothers Three Stooges movie.

Larry: Alaskan Senator Ted Stevens
Moe: Elle Fanning
Curly: Freddie Prinze Jr.

Larry: Dane Cook
Moe: Paul Giamatti
Curly: A plate of bacon-wrapped jalapeno poppers

Larry: Dax Shepard
Moe: M'onique
Curly: The ghost of Susan Sontag

Larry: Peter Falk
Moe: A Tamagootchi keychain
Curly: Dr. Drew

Honestly, some of those still make more sense than the actual cast. Write it down, Hollywood. The Three Stooges 2: The Edge of Reason is going to be 2013's Slumdog Milliona[gunshot].

Posted by Gabe at 5:30 PM in
Tags:  |  |  |  |




28 Comments

spectator

where did dax shepard get that stomach? i'm a little less disappointed with kristen bell.

except that i'm not.

Posted by: spectator profile link at 03/25/09 5:41 PM | Reply
Score = 7 Vote up Vote down

that is totally dax shepard's head shopped onto my body.

Posted by: fuckstick in reply to spectator's comment at 03/25/09 5:46 PM | Reply
Score = 8 Vote up Vote down

i don't know. after seeing the last movie that plate of bacon-wrapped jalapeno poppers was in, i'm not sure it has the range.

Posted by: rane at 03/25/09 5:43 PM | Reply
Score = 29 Vote up Vote down
Godsauce

You're crazy, Gabe. It sounds like they found the best possible cast for a Three Stooges movie. Really, it makes me actually want to see a Three Stooges movie by the Farrelly Bros.

Posted by: Godsauce profile link at 03/25/09 5:45 PM | Reply
Score = -10 Vote up Vote down
Pavimento

Then the're going to make the remake of nosferatu with sean penn?

Posted by: Pavimento profile link at 03/25/09 5:45 PM | Reply
Score = -4 Vote up Vote down
hlebtastic

I think the weirdest part is that Sean Penn and Benicio would consider taking these parts.

Posted by: hlebtastic profile link at 03/25/09 5:48 PM | Reply
Score = 10 Vote up Vote down
I PEE GOLD

Sean Penn? Benicio Del Toro? What the fuck?

Posted by: I PEE GOLD profile link at 03/25/09 5:52 PM | Reply
Score = 5 Vote up Vote down
grace6697

THIS IS INSANE.

Posted by: grace6697 profile link at 03/25/09 6:01 PM | Reply
Score = 4 Vote up Vote down
trevormail

They should just pick three random low-ranking dudes from the Sopranos. Like... Vinnie from Doogie Howser, Bobby Bucco, and what's his fuck.

Posted by: trevormail profile link at 03/25/09 6:10 PM | Reply
Score = 8 Vote up Vote down
Carrie

I already know this is annoying but *Tamagotchi.

Well I wish the studios had called me first because my ideal cast would probably definitely be Dane Cook, Jeff Dunham, and Carlos Mencia. WHAT WERE THEY THINKING.

Posted by: Carrie profile link at 03/25/09 6:29 PM | Reply
Score = 11 Vote up Vote down
Jeb

i will go see this movie if the call it 'two oscar winners and fat jim carey.'

Posted by: Jeb profile link at 03/25/09 6:29 PM | Reply
Score = 16 Vote up Vote down
bingo gas station

Hmmm... How about?

Posted by: bingo gas station profile link at 03/25/09 6:50 PM | Reply
Score = 46 Vote up Vote down

To be fair, Sean Penn is a pretty accomplished character/comedic actor (see Spicoli). I'd like to see him do more comedy, actually. Jim Carrey still has potential, even if he picks shitty projects. Benicio Del Toro is just bizarre, though. The thing I really don't get is how they're going to update the humor. Straight slapstick is incredibly hard to do well and even harder to make fly with audiences these days. I'll take the bet that that joke with the one guy swinging a board around on his shoulders appears in this movie within the first ten minutes.

Posted by: zack at 03/25/09 6:53 PM | Reply
Score = 6 Vote up Vote down
Kenny Powers

What this movie needs is a cameo by Sexman in the role of Shemp.

Image and video hosting by TinyPic

Posted by: Kenny Powers profile link at 03/25/09 7:01 PM | Reply
Score = 15 Vote up Vote down
Benjamin Coale

i read that it would be johnny depp instead of benicio del toro.

Posted by: Da Cake Eatur profile link at 03/25/09 7:09 PM | Reply
Score = 4 Vote up Vote down
MarkyBob

This movie will be either a total disaster or a total disaster.

Posted by: MarkyBob profile link at 03/25/09 10:10 PM | Reply
Score = 17 Vote up Vote down

OH YOUR GOD the 3rd group HAS GOT to be made into a movie. I would totally watch that, it'd just be too funny.

Posted by: doobie at 03/25/09 10:28 PM | Reply
Score = 1 Vote up Vote down

i literally saw this two days ago on IMDB and it had johnny depp playing moe. weird.

Posted by: seth at 03/25/09 11:21 PM | Reply
Score = 1 Vote up Vote down
Mcluskyist

Might be worth it to see Jim Carrey slapped repeatedly....

Nope, still sounds like a hot pile of shit.

Posted by: Mcluskyist profile link at 03/25/09 11:22 PM | Reply
Score = 2 Vote up Vote down
Huh?

Is it too early to nominate this for The WMOAT?

Posted by: Huh? profile link at 03/26/09 1:11 AM | Reply
Score = 3 Vote up Vote down

just have all three of them played by Mark Gormley.

Posted by: Liam at 03/26/09 2:39 AM | Reply
Score = 6 Vote up Vote down

I pick the last option. Dr. Drew, Falk, and Virtual Pets? Sure fire hit. best line up of the bunch, including that first one.. honestly, who would cast those three as the stooges. that is just a silly prediction.... wait....

Posted by: Brian at 03/26/09 5:02 AM | Reply
Score = 0 Vote up Vote down

only if that picture of Penn, Carey and Del Toro was a bit more real. Penn would fire and go through all three of them, saving them from having to do this movie.

Posted by: Brian at 03/26/09 5:05 AM | Reply
Score = 0 Vote up Vote down

The ghosts of the original Stooges are not happy, call studio execs "a bunch of knuckleheads"

http://weeklyworldnews.com/celebs/7151/three-stooges-movie/

Posted by: grizzlyfish at 03/26/09 11:14 AM | Reply
Score = 0 Vote up Vote down

John C. Reilly would make a good stooge.

Posted by: moi at 03/26/09 12:57 PM | Reply
Score = 5 Vote up Vote down

That's real talk, actually. How about John C. Reilly (Larry), Phillip Seymour Hoffman (Moe), and John Goodman (Curly)?

Posted by: sam profile link in reply to moi's comment at 03/26/09 1:48 PM | Reply
Score = 2 Vote up Vote down
josephscott

I think the film is probably going to be about the lives of the Stooges off the screen - i.e. their private lives - hence, the casting.

Posted by: josephscott profile link at 04/02/09 1:27 AM | Reply
Score = 1 Vote up Vote down

you're lost on this post. this cast sounds perfect. this is why you write a blog and they make movies.

Posted by: claw00 at 04/02/09 10:19 AM | Reply
Score = -1 Vote up Vote down

Leave a comment


Staff

  • Founder/Editor-In-Chief: Scott Lapatine
  • Senior Editor: Gabe Delahaye
  • Executive Editor: Amrit Singh

Info

Contact

You Can Make It Up logo
Gabe loves fan fiction. You Can Make It Up features his own personal alternate adventures starring some of our favorite characters.

You Can Make It Up: People Tell Carrie Prejean What An Asshole She Is

Carrie Prejean turned the video camera off, put on some clothes, and stepped out of her house. It was a beautiful day outside. The air smelled like apples, and the late morning light hit the world in just such a...

MORE »

The Hunt For The Worst Movie Of All Time logo
After watching Death Sentence, a terrible movie starring Kevin Bacon as a father in search of vigilante justice directed by Saw's James Wan, Gabe embarked on The Hunt For The Worst Movie of All Time. This is his sad journey.

The Hunt For The Worst Movie Of All Time: In The Land Of The Women

If you are a sassy and sarcastic young man in an American sitcom who represents the sitcom writer's desire that a nerdy Jewish teenager can somehow be the desirable romantic hero in this world, then eventually you will get a...

MORE »

Monsters' Ball logo
This week's five highest rated comments as voted on by you, the lowest rated comment as voted on by you, and the editor's choice.

Monsters' Ball: The Week's Best Comments

I shouldn't even be here right now. I SHOULD BE GETTING INTO MY COSTUME! If I don't hurry, my facepaint won't be dry before I get to the MOONVIE theater, and everyone will be like "hahah, you look like you're...

MORE »

Double Dog logo
Blogging about TV and movies isn't all fun and videogames. Every week, Lindsay or Gabe will be presented with a physical or mental challenge that tests their bravery,patience, and taste.

Double Dog: I Took A TV Bus Tour Alone In A "Just Jack" Tshirt

The Challenge: I had to go on a 3.5 hour bus tour of totally random TV and film locations in New York City. Alone, and wearing a specific ridiculous tshirt. And I had to find someone to take my picture...

MORE »

Videogum Movie Club logo
Let's all go to the movies, and let's all see the same movie, and let's discuss it here.

The Videogum Movie Club: 2012

Uh. OK. Well, first let's address what this movie did well, like the disappointed parents we are (or at least that I am), recognizing that the negative feedback won't be useful or constructive if it isn't preceded by something positive....

MORE »