Oh my god. This is amazing, and even if it’s a joke it’s still hilarious: guy tries to cover NMH’s “In The Aeroplane Over The Sea,” and from the fourth word of the song, it’s clear things aren’t going to work out…and it just gets worse from there. (You have to know the song, but even Stephen Colbert knows the song, so I think we’re good here):

This is the version of the song I’m going to sing over everyone else on my next road trip. Actually, I’m going to rip this to mp3 and play IT instead. I just bookmarked this video to come back to whenever I’m feeling sad. Licorice! It couldn’t be better. (Via the everybody cares tumblr.)

Related Posts:

  • No Related Posts
Kids Eulogize Their Dead Fish In The Toilet The Darndest Things
30 Rock: Muppets, Lemon's Secret Past, And YouTube
Comments (60)
  1. ronton  |   Posted on Mar 27th, 2009

    video not there any more :(

    • Lindsay  |   Posted on Mar 27th, 2009

      Yes, it is. It’s that thing YouTube does sometimes. Always try twice.

  2. hlebtastic  |   Posted on Mar 27th, 2009

    He mixed two of my favorite things, NMH and licorice, so obviously this is pure win

  3. ber  |   Posted on Mar 27th, 2009

    He sure can hit those high notes!

  4. joaquin phoenix  |   Posted on Mar 27th, 2009

    i know hipster-targeted tongue in cheek performance art when i see it!

  5. John Ham  |   Posted on Mar 27th, 2009

    Haha, oh man, I got nothing, this video just hit me in the right way.

  6. Steve  |   Posted on Mar 27th, 2009

    I love the swing in the guitar chords. Makes it sound like Sinatra should be singing.

  7. noah   |   Posted on Mar 27th, 2009

    i have decided that “licorice” is my new default zinger. i.e. this video is licorice!

  8. noah   |   Posted on Mar 27th, 2009

    i have decided that “licorice” is my new default zinger. i.e. this video is licorice!

  9. Blondie  |   Posted on Mar 27th, 2009

    I love this kid. “They gave it to me cus I taught them how to make weird sounds.” Licorice!

  10. Aaron  |   Posted on Mar 27th, 2009

    thanks for posting my video and im glad you guys enjoyed it!

  11. Rebecca  |   Posted on Mar 27th, 2009

    Nope. You’re all wrong. It’s the Sunn O))) amp that’s the best part.

  12. Alex Hudson  |   Posted on Mar 27th, 2009

    Thst was epic. The best bit is when he’s done singing, and rocks out on the guitar chords for a while.

  13. Uncle Grambo  |   Posted on Mar 27th, 2009

    And you wonder why they don’t have Neutral Milk Hotel night on IDOL?

  14. Christo  |   Posted on Mar 27th, 2009

    Simply amazing, this is art

  15. GwaR  |   Posted on Mar 27th, 2009

    /MUNICIPAL WASTE\

  16. steve  |   Posted on Mar 27th, 2009

    WORST version EVER?!?
    Has no one ever heard the Matt Pond cover?

    • Lindsay  |   Posted on Mar 27th, 2009

      OMG, finally someone else. Finally. I’m forced to listen to that like once a week!

    • cherry  |   Posted on Mar 30th, 2009

      Oh god, that song is one of the worst pieces of shit to ever have violated my aural cavities. Seriously. It almost makes me wish I had never even heard the original, because listening to Matt Pond cover it is like watching someone kill something beautiful.

      What I?m trying to say (to be explicit) is that Matt Pond?s cover of In the Aeroplane Over the Sea is an aborted unicorn fetus. Metaphorically speaking.

  17. Jeb  |   Posted on Mar 27th, 2009

    he is an expert on the weird noises. he is dr. weird noises.

  18. mtrax  |   Posted on Mar 27th, 2009

    god! what a daymaker… i’m shaking with joy!!!

  19. bree  |   Posted on Mar 27th, 2009

    nmh is one of the best bands to sing along with purely for all the crazy “eeeeeee”’s. i basically sing that exact version- mangled, wrong lyrics and over-enthusiastic wails- of that song every time im in my car listening to the album, even though i’ve heard it ten million times. kudos to this brave young man.

  20. Kevin Barre  |   Posted on Mar 27th, 2009

    He no doubt brings the house down with “Oh Comely.”

  21. Kevin Barre  |   Posted on Mar 27th, 2009

    He no doubt brings the house down with “Oh Comely.”

  22. Mary Mouse  |   Posted on Mar 27th, 2009

    I am posting this on so many people’s Facebook walls. THANK YOU LINDSAY!

  23. TalbainJ  |   Posted on Mar 27th, 2009

    THE ONLY GIRL I’VE EVER LOOOOOOOOVED
    WAS BORN WITH LICORICE IN HER EYES
    AND THEN THEY BURIED HER ALIVE
    ONE SOMETHING 1945
    SOMETHING EEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE

  24. rick  |   Posted on Mar 27th, 2009

    stephen colbert knows NMH? Can anyone provide a link to this???

    • meANDmy_mONKEY  |   Posted on Mar 27th, 2009

      Lindsay wrote about it on her personal website here here. I don’t think there is video of the event.

      • jim  |   Posted on Mar 30th, 2009

        No cameras in the studio?

  25. rick  |   Posted on Mar 27th, 2009

    stephen colbert knows NMH? Can anyone provide a link to this???

  26. I PEE GOLD  |   Posted on Mar 27th, 2009

    “LET ME EAT LICORICE!” HAHAHAHA, what?

  27. jacob666  |   Posted on Mar 27th, 2009

    everyone in my office just died from “hilarity overload.”

  28. Rebecca  |   Posted on Mar 27th, 2009

    Um…you guys know this is a joke right? like he’s making fun of NMH coverers. he’s not the worst, he’s the best at pretending to be the worst.

  29. meANDmy_mONKEY  |   Posted on Mar 27th, 2009

    Hidden due to low comment rating. Click here to see.

    • Carrie  |   Posted on Mar 27th, 2009

      Come on, dude, it’s just NMH. Jeff Mangum isn’t even dead. It’s not like he’s making fun of Katrina victims, or using a dead terrorist puppet to get big laffs, or even acting like the song is his when it’s clearly not besides being delivered so much worse than the original song. No one does that!

      • Rebecca  |   Posted on Mar 28th, 2009

        Straight for real! Carrie is the best at commenting on videogum. No irony pills.

  30. meANDmy_mONKEY  |   Posted on Mar 27th, 2009

    I’m going to have to listen to the entire album now to recover from this

  31. Seitz  |   Posted on Mar 27th, 2009

    He had me at hey, hey, hey, hey, hey.

  32. Drew  |   Posted on Mar 27th, 2009

    This kid hates indie white kids

  33. Seattle Show Gal  |   Posted on Mar 27th, 2009

    Did that guy really record himself??? and then he had the audacity to put it online??? YIKES!!!

  34. square jordan  |   Posted on Mar 27th, 2009

    Requesting MY GIRLS…. so many bad acoustic youtube kid covers already!

  35. spencer  |   Posted on Mar 27th, 2009

    you mean best nmh cover of all time.

  36. gokinsmen  |   Posted on Mar 27th, 2009

    Worst ever is Amanda Palmer doing Two Headed Boy, Part I. I don’t even want to think about it…my ears start hurting preemptively.

    • langford  |   Posted on Mar 28th, 2009

      Amanda’s all about theatrics. Jeff’s all about restraint. It was bound to fail.

  37. indybree  |   Posted on Mar 27th, 2009

    Thankfully, nothing can ever ruin Neutral Milk Hotel for me.

  38. sunn OHHHH!  |   Posted on Mar 28th, 2009

    sunn 0))) + municipal waste + neutral milk hotel = theoretically the best, but actually the worst

  39. Zero7teen  |   Posted on Mar 28th, 2009

    This is the best video ever.

  40. Chelsea  |   Posted on Mar 28th, 2009

    Amazingly, this WASN’T the Dreadful Dolls cover.

  41. Lisa  |   Posted on Mar 28th, 2009

    Hey this guy is pure genius. God bless the womb that carried thee!

  42. sinkfloridasink  |   Posted on Mar 29th, 2009

    NEUTRAL MILK HOTEL DOESN’T CARE ABOUT BLACK PEOPLE

    • Elk  |   Posted on Mar 30th, 2009

      The world doesn’t care about you.

  43. Dave Tha Killa  |   Posted on Mar 29th, 2009

    no doubt, the kid can thrash

  44. Mandy  |   Posted on Mar 30th, 2009

    oh no no no.

  45. tactfulcactus  |   Posted on Mar 30th, 2009

    joke or not, I like that guy.

  46. Erin K.  |   Posted on Mar 30th, 2009

    The Municipal Waste shirt lets me know this has GOT to be a joke. WASTE!

  47. Jon  |   Posted on Mar 31st, 2009

    You know it’s going to be bad when the dude tries to pass off his shitty Marshall MG amp as a Sunn.

  48. indierocksucks.com  |   Posted on Mar 31st, 2009

    this fuckin rules.

  49. nicolas cage in a bear suit  |   Posted on Apr 1st, 2009

    if this is really a NMH parody, there aren’t nearly enough semen references.

  50. Big Red  |   Posted on Apr 3rd, 2009

    I blame this video for me hardly listening to any song that isn’t “In the Aeroplane Over the Sea” at all.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post, reply to, or rate a comment.