Sign Up
Sign In
Follow:
  • Photos
  • Viral Videos
  • Recaps
  • Trailers
Featured Stories 
Videogum Summer School Is Back In Session
Videogum Summer School Is Back In…
Which Tertiary 1990′s Character Should (Shouldn’t) Get His/Her Own Prequel?
Which Tertiary 1990′s Character Should…
Now Hiring: Videogum Summer Interns
Now Hiring: Videogum Summer Interns
None Of Rihanna’s Lines Of Dialogue From Battleship
None Of Rihanna’s Lines Of Dialogue…
Mad Men: Oh Right, Advertising
Mad Men: Oh Right, Advertising
Kristen Stewart Has The World’s Shittiest Life
Kristen Stewart Has The World’s…
 

Primetime: What Would You Do?: The Stupid Man’s Dateline: To Catch A Predator

Posted on Mar 18th, 2009 by Lindsay Robertson 15 Comments TweetShare

xwg-vxyajsk.jpg

I’ve actually been keeping up with the unbelievably pointless Primetime series “What Would You Do?”, but last night my DVR, in an act of inanimate object tough love, “forgot” to tape it. Lucky for me, The Hater caught the latest episode, which, as usual, used a completely fake setup and hidden camera in order to goad bystanders into taking action and ask viewers to fake-search our fake-hearts about what we would do in the fake situation. Except this time they’ve gone to far. Last night’s question was: “What would we do if we were in a restaurant and overheard a group of fundamentalist Latter Day Saints attempting to convince a child to become a grown man’s third wife?” No, seriously: that’s the premise. With costumes!

Even though previous episodes have featured outlandish scenarios (a man hitting a woman in a public park in broad daylight three feet away from passersby, a deli worker screaming racial slurs at customers), they at least fell within the category of “Things regular people have witnessed before, in the world.” But this scenario, in which a secretive, segregationist cult conducts business for which they’ve been recently mass hauled off to jail in the middle of a restaurant just would. not. happen. Somebody needs to tell John Quinones that Big Love is just a big fake TV show.

Also, if you do tune in in the future to this infuriatingly ridiculous show, keep watch for the best part of almost every episode: when John Quinones approaches a bystander and reveals who he is, and nobody ever recognizes him, ever, and he’s always surprised by it. Chris Hansen-sized ego on that guy.

TweetShareTags: Dateline, John Quinones, Mormons, Primetime 
The Dr. Dove Commercials Will Make You Scared Of The Dentist Again
The Time Has Come To Defend Kristen Stewart
Comments (15)
  1. Ugah  |   Posted on Mar 18th, 2009

    YOU JUST GOT PUNK’D!

    Reply
  2. CarolineA  |   Posted on Mar 18th, 2009

    I miss To Catch A Predator =[[ As much as pedophilia is terrible, it’s MUCH more entertaining for an hour than this is.

    Reply
  3. Darren87  |   Posted on Mar 18th, 2009

    As I’ve come to terms with being a douchebag I can comfortably say I would do nothing. Yay for not getting involved!

    Reply
  4. DanBlurns  |   Posted on Mar 18th, 2009

    Primetime: What Would You Do?! You’re in a record store, and a child attempts to purchase the new Nickelback CD.

    Reply
    • CarolineA  |   Posted on Mar 18th, 2009

      How about Primetime: What Would You Do?! Your roommate is about to watch a Mind of Mencias Marathon.

      Reply
      • .bryan.  |   Posted on Mar 18th, 2009

        Murder/suicide.

        Reply
  5. Chadams  |   Posted on Mar 18th, 2009

    Not that I ever made plans to join Twitter, but hearing John Quinones asking the viewers to contact him via Twitter at the end ensured that I’ll never touch that website. And I thought Martin Bashir was going to be the blight on ABC’s news team… (John Stossel notwithstanding).

    Reply
  6. kevin  |   Posted on Mar 18th, 2009

    4 and a half minute douchchill

    Reply
  7. JSuzart  |   Posted on Mar 18th, 2009

    Hahahaha good SNL sketch. The black jacket lesbian was hilarious!

    Reply
  8. Ben  |   Posted on Mar 19th, 2009

    The rage I feel toward Utah polygamists far, far, outweighs the rage I feel toward a show trying to get people to fuck with them.

    Reply
  9. Ben  |   Posted on Mar 19th, 2009

    I love ow the premise is Punk’d but ‘the surprise, we gotchya line!’ is a solemn “You’re a hero and we want to congratulate you”

    Reply
  10. BluCheez  |   Posted on Mar 19th, 2009

    I got filmed in one of that idiots segments in Hoboken. They had a kid wimpering on the sidewalk and I walked right past. Figured he was waiting on someone to get out of a car. 1/2 a block later a bunch of producers were getting people to sign release statements and asking if they saw the kid. Idiots.

    http://hoboken411.com/archives/8928

    Reply
  11. Genevieve  |   Posted on Mar 19th, 2009

    Never watched the show, but this episode sounds ridiculous. While the FLDS & what they’re doing in regards to child molestation is disgusting, they would not be talking about it at a resturant. For one, the FLDS groups do not go out into society with the kids & talk about this stuff & for two, the girls don’t need to be talked into marrying someone, they just have to do it or they are convinced they are going to hell. This show is making a mockery of a serious situation in my opinion. As a former mormon & a human being, this issue gets my blood boiling.

    Reply
  12. Beat  |   Posted on Mar 20th, 2009

    I actually saw this…it’s so stupid..it would never happen!

    “are you a good person?”

    I would guess that 75% (at most) wouldn’t care about someone else’s problems

    Reply
  13. Brittany  |   Posted on Apr 4th, 2009

    This is in response to the people knocking this show. I actually think this show opens peoples eyes to the messed up sh** that still happens today. As ridiculous as this episode was, this still happens, and its ignorant to think it doesnt. Everyone wants to believe rasicm is dead but this show also shows that, rasicm is still obviously present today. While people watch staged shows like, survivor, the hills and “reality” tv without saying a negative word, a show comes along that points out the real problems in this fuc*** up country, people bash it?? Ok maybe they should do an episiode showing how unintelligent the people in this country are.

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Login
Click here to cancel reply.

You must be logged in to post, reply to, or rate a comment.

01 Game Of Thrones Open Thread
02 Videogum Summer School Is Back In Session
03 Dan Harmon Replaced As Community Show Runner
04 Fine, The Great Gatsby Trailer, You Guys
05 Monsters’ Ball: The Week’s Best Comments
01 Duh Aficionado Magazine: Kate Gosselin’s “...
02 Who Should Play Linda Blair In The TV Adaption Of The Exor...
03 Leonardo DiCaprio Eating Soup
04 Hey, You Guys Like Punk Music?
05 Mad Men: Oh Right, Advertising
01 Game Of Thrones Open Thread
02 Videogum Summer School Is Back In Session
03 Dan Harmon Replaced As Community Show Runner
04 Fine, The Great Gatsby Trailer, You Guys
05 Monsters’ Ball: The Week’s Best Comments
Social 
This week's five highest rated comments as voted on by you, the lowest rated comment as voted on by you, and the editor's choice.
  • The Week's Best Comments
  • A Friendly Chat With Gabe And Kelly: Anderson Cooper VS. "The Human Barbie"
  • The Videogum Why Don't YOU Caption It? Contest: B-Hole At The Zoo
  • BNPG: Talk Show Sequels
'Sup, pogs!
  • Hunger Games Barbie Doll
Let's all go to the movies, and let's all see the same movie, and let's discuss it here.
  • Damsels In Distress
  • A Fake Interview With Uggie, The Dog From The Artist
Gabe loves fan fiction. You Can Make It Up features his own personal alternate adventures starring some of our favorite characters.
  • Mark Wahlberg Stops World War II
After watching Death Sentence, a terrible movie starring Kevin Bacon as a father in search of vigilante justice directed by Saw's James Wan, Gabe embarked on The Hunt For The Worst Movie of All Time. This is his sad journey.
  • Greenberg

About  /   Terms & Conditions  /  Privacy Policy  /  Copyright Policy  /  BUZZMEDIA  /  Stereogum
Sign In:
Lost your password?
Login Sign up
An email will be sent to the address of the account
Cancel  
Sign Up:
Login Sign in
LostPassword:
A message will be sent to the email address of the account.