I love Halloween episodes of shows! The only thing better than a Halloween episode of a show is a Christmas episode of a show! And the only thing better than a Christmas episode of a show is an episode of a show that is just a stand-out good episode without having a gimmick attached! That being said, last night’s Halloween episodes were not the best Halloween episodes I’ve ever seen. Community was fine, and I like the idea of having each character tell their own Halloween story, but how it was carried out — especially considering how it was surrounded by the idea of Britta finding the personality test psycho — kind of felt rushed, or at least not thought out enough. Parks and Recreation was fine too, but I wasn’t really into the Entertainment 720 plot, and was only kind of confused when Aziz had that nice Lesie Knope tribute video all along. I know it’s a comedy, but, What? What a weird twist! The parts that took place at the Aubrey Plaza party were great, though. The Office was also just fine. Loved the Jesse costume. There were two funny lines. One of them was when Pam said, “Dwight, are you eating a stick?” The other oneeeee I forget. I’m sure you remember, though. Wasn’t that funny?! LOL. Whitney was perfect as usual. I loved It’s Always Sunny. It was very loud and weird, but I loved it WHAT CAN I SAY. More importantly, what can you guys say? About these things?

Comments (131)
  1. COMMUNITY: C+. It would have been hard to top the great alternate-realities episode of two weeks ago, and the similarities (a tale told from the perspective of each character) makes the comparison all the more painful. There were some great flashes throughout, but overall a Brittaed episode. Its disappointing quality is sadly pretty much on par with this rest of season.

    Side note: I think I’ve figured out The Walking Dead and my frustration with it: it’s written by Britta but I wish it was written by Abed.

    PARKS AND RECREATION: B-. Okay? Just okay. Kelly summed it up. I don’t have anything else to say about it.

    THE OFFICE: B-. A typically mediocre episode, but some great lines. Besides the root line:
    “She’s from somewhere, I bet. Maybe from the forest.”
    “Yeah. Seems like there isn’t even a narrative. Maybe the filmmaker realized that even narrative is comforting.”

    IT’S ALWAYS SUNNY IN PHILADELPHIA: B. Like Kelly, probably my favorite episode of the night, but it seemed to fizzle out quickly from the amazing premise. Let me break it down. ACT 1: A. The initial explanation of the game and its levels and its byzantine rules. Amazing. The board getting nailed down for Mac’s sake and Mac’s cheerful admission that he’d no doubt forget and try to flip the board over anyway was pretty hilarious. ACT 2: B. The actual playing of the game was still pretty good—I liked the dog kennel—but it wasn’t quite as funny as Act 1. ACT 3: C-. So limp. I realize that was kind of the point—a lame coin toss ending—but it was still a disappointing third act after such a great first act.

  2. Also, and I can’t believe I’m saying this, but I would have probably had a better time watching baseball last night than sitcoms. !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  3. Community was my favorite kind of Potbong.

  4. Oddly enough, I think the League was the winner of the night, just eeking past Sunny. Off night I guess?

  5. missed the FX shows and apparently a fucking awesome ball game for a pretty mediocre stretch of shows…i still love the Office even though everyone else seems to be over it.

    had to rewind twice when Erin pulled out pecker poker. so great.

    • I like The Office too, I think if you go into something expecting to hate it it’s a self-fulfilling prophecy.
      I mean here’s a gif of Erin

      • Erin’s so cute.

      • I can’t wait for The Erin Show spin off. I think I’m going to delete everything off of my DVR to make space, just in case this becomes a real thing that really happens.

      • LOOK, YOU are welcome to like THE SHOW. THAT’S great. BUT THERE’S just no FUCKING way you can TELL ME it’s even anywhere near THE SAME DAMN show it use to BE. WATCHING OLD episodes of THAT SHIT and then fastforwarding to THIS SEASON where OSCAR–one of the more grounded CHARACTERS in the Office–is smashing car windows AND PEOPLE ARE clapping at a character POURING SHIT into a random person’s car is FUCKING BIZARRE and doesn’t even seem REAL.

        AND KEVIN. HOLY fuck anything with Keven.

        • Is this comment supposed to be read in Christopher Walken’s voice? I’m not understanding all the CAPS.

        • Not being as good as it used to be doesn’t mean it isn’t good. Just that it used to be better. It’s still better than most other stuff out there, and still watchable. It would be very hard for many shows to maintain a high quality for a long time, and it would hardly do it by being stagnant. So, unless shows stop once they hit their peak, that’s going to be a constant problem. And it would also mean that television quality would go down as most great shows on a downward slide are still better than most of the other crap out there.

  6. god bless beavis and butthead. welcome home, fart knockers.

  7. Abed humming the song on the radio was the best part of the night. So good. But I agree, otherwise, kind of lukewarm across the board.

    Also, because Facetaco, famously, loves Suburgatory, I gave it a shot. Jury’s still out, but that’s not the point. The point is, I also watched Modern Family and Happy Endings for the first time (due to inertia) and Matt Besser was on both. Way to go Matt Besser!

  8. “You’re beautiful! On the inside. Where your spirit lives.”

  9. We need some Gangsta Trobed up in here. Community was fun but pretty empty of substance. And after Chaos Theory I am going to be looking at most episodes this season and thinking “you could be so much better than this”.

  10. I play this game every Thursday called “See how much of Whitney I can watch.” It’s never very much. And I figured out one of the problems with the show, It’s Whitney! (As in the person, not the show, although the show isn’t really helping itself) She’s always smiling, at least in the first few moments of the show I always watch. It’s like she’s really excited to say her next line and thinks it’s SO HILARIOUS that she’s on a sitcom and doesn’t everyone agree?

    • “Plus she has a HUGE mouth” – Julia Roberts

    • As I’ve mentioned before, I tend to be too lazy to change the channel, and I catch most of Whitney, and what I simply cannot get over is what a HORRIBLE FUCKING AWFUL TERRIBLE person she is! She is like some kind of nightmare representation of the worst kind of female stereotype, and her (fake pretend tv) boyfriend is like “oh, you’re so crazy, that’s why i love you” and I am like “no she is a manipulative BITCH who ruins your jeans and puts HIDDEN CAMERAS IN YOUR HOUSE!!! Get out of there!!!” Unfortunately, I can’t seem to stop hate-watching this mess.

  11. I thought Community was very good. It was definitely weird to have two consecutive episodes with such similar gimmicks, but a) apparently the timeline one was supposed to be earlier in the season and b) I actually thought last night’s worked better. The stories flowed into each other more naturally and it was easier to justify their differences since they came from different characters’ perspectives. Which left more time for LAFFS (as opposed to repeating lines seven times over, which wasn’t not funny, don’t get me wrong)

  12. Okay I watched the cold open of Whitney because I had no idea what it was and it pretty much did the exact type of cold open that Louie made fun of in the ‘Oh Louie’ episode, complete with the ‘I love you despite you being an asshole’ look at the end.

  13. I only watch P&R, but I thought everyone was being kind of terrible? Like what was April’s problem? Normally I love her but I just wanted to punch her face last night. And Tom ruining Leslie’s thing–although I am glad she went off on him. I’m glad Ann’s getting some non-Leslie time. I’m sick of the Chris-and-Jerry’s-daughter thing already. Why was Donna only there for one scene? Yay for Oren. And can we please get Ben and Leslie back together already?

    • What was your problem w/ April? She didn’t do anything especially terrible, she was pretty much her normal self. She even stuck up for Jerry (!) in the closing tag.

      • I felt like she knew why Ben was mad and just played along with Dumb Andy. Andy plays oblivious so well, but it just came off as mean-spirited when April didn’t acknowledge that it was a dick move to not let Ben know about the party.

        • They did sort of point out how each of them was treating their roommates like their siblings, and her messing with him was her way of treating him like family (just like Ben’s passive aggressiveness, and Andy’s play fighting)


  14. Inspector Spacetime forever!

  15. I would like to request a gif of Andy moving Ben’s lips for him at the party, please! That was my favorite part of the night!

  16. I loved Community last night. I seriously can’t decide whose story I loved the most.


  17. So Ryan was Jesse Pinkman right?

  18. I thought Community was great last night. Britta reading the book ‘Warren Peace’ in her account of how one of them would kill everyone else I thought was the best, such a small detail but so true to her character.

  19. The world needs a Robert California “Deal with it” gif with replaced sunglasses! NEEDZ!

  20. What about Happy Endings Halloween Ep? If you weren’t dying of laughter watching Max in that Baby Bjorn with those tiny little doll arms, then I am not sure we can be friends.

  21. But Whitney was great, AMIRITE?

  22. HELICOPTER BITCH!

  23. Parks and Rec, as usual, I found to be the winner of the night. Mostly, for these two lines:

    “Oh, the shock wire. I call it that because when you take a shower and your touch it, you die. ha ha”

    “A hammer, half a pretzel, a cartridge that says sonic and hedgehog, half a scissors, and a flashlight…full of jellybeans”

    I watched that last one a couple times, and couldn’t stop laughing. I could watch a show entirely centered around Ron Swanson.

  24. I can’t believe there are 100 comments

  25. I’m gonna go out on a root here and say The Office was the best of the night. Gabe was especially excellent as super awkward creepy guy.

  26. Also, I know this falls under the category of too stupid to be credible, but Kevin’s cluelessness about mummies was really funny to me.

  27. I don’t know if anyone accidentally left the TV on like me (“Sure,” you’re thinking, “accidentally”), but if so maybe you noticed that KEN MARINO was on Whitney. I had mixed feelings about this!

Leave a Reply

Login

You must be logged in to post, reply to, or rate a comment.