Let me just say first of all that sometimes it is more fun to want something than to actually get/have it. The pleasure is in the anticipation! (Of course, sometimes you want something and then you get it and it’s the best to finally have that thing you wanted.) (And thus begins and ends Gabe’s Big Bathroom Book of Condescending Truisms.) And now let me go on to say that Amelia, a biopic about the life of Amelia Earhart, starring Hilary Swank and the finest set of fake teeth $50 can buy, and Richard Gere doing an Academy Award-winning Mr. Magoo impersonation if the Academy gave out an award specifically for people’s Mr. Magoo impersonations, is a terrible movie! THE HUNT, IT IS CLEAR, IS BACK ON. It is worth pointing out that biopics always suck and are always the worst. The complications and messiness of an actual human life without any discernible narrative arc reduced to plot points and swelling music against an historical (but malleable) backdrop featuring actors doing funny voices, all towards a falsely redemptive or emotive outcome is insulting to anyone who actually takes an interest in the genuine histories of historical figures, but should really just be gross to anyone who has, you know, been a human being alive on Earth.

But Amelia sucks and is the worst for specific reasons in addition to the general ones listed above. So let’s talk about those:

Amelia Earhart used to run through the corn and dream of flying or some shit. So then one day she went to Richard Gere’s office and was like “I want to fly across the ocean,” and he was like, “But you’re a lady,” and she’s like, “yeah,” and he’s like, “OK.” So actually, that was pretty easy. She overcame all the hurtles of telling someone she definitely wanted to do something and waiting for them to tell her she could do it two seconds later. (I’m teasing, I’m sure Amelia Earhart overcame lots of obstacles, which would be just the kind of dramatic thing to put into a movie about her life, but oh well, maybe they’re saving all of that stuff for Amelia 2: Full Throttle. And then the rest of the movie is basically about stuff that happens in her life. She definitely did a bunch of stuff (flying stuff, mostly) that women had never done before, and was a huge inspiration to the ladiez. She also cheated on her husband. And talked A LOT about not wanting to be tied down and wanting freedom in a way that you might think a lesbian might talk about not wanting to be tied down and wanting freedom, JUST SAYING. Eventually, after being the first lady to fly across the ocean as a passenger, and then being the first lady to fly across the ocean as a solo pilot, she decides that she’s going to be the first woman to fly around the world, and then she dies. R.I.P. OR DOES SHE?! She does.

There’s a really funny moment at the very beginning of the movie when Amelia Earhart first walks into Richard Gere’s office, which, incidentally, he’s a publisher? But somehow he is also in the business of organizing airplane rides for daring women? It’s a little confusing. Anyway: Amelia Earhart says that she wants to be the first woman to cross the Atlantic Ocean, and Richard Gere asks her why she wants to fly, to which she responds, “why do men ride horses?” BOOM! In your face, Richard Gere! I think we’re supposed to recognize her as a very brassy lady who won’t take no for an answer, but wouldn’t a better question be “why do men fly?” Maybe it’s just a generation gap thing, but I’m not sure I see the correlation between women flying in airplanes and men riding horses. That’s like telling someone you want a cup of coffee and when they ask why you want a cup of coffee you ask them why men ride horses. Also: WOMEN BE SHOPPIN!

Speaking of funny, this makes me laugh to no end whatsoever:

Of course, as with any biopic, the whole thing is just so HEAVY, as if somehow a felt flapper hat actually MEANS something. And also BORING. Every time Amelia sets off on a new airplane ride, there is a graphic that pops up on the screen with a countdown of how many miles she has left. You know. Until she DIES. LOL. “1946 miles left.” Hahahha. It should read “1946 miles of napping and half-paying attention left,” because it’s already bad enough when you know how the story ends without a graphic telling you how long you have to wait for the thing you already know about. And what drama they might have cooked up just disappears without mention, for example when Richard Gere bribes a young woman to lose an airplane race so as not to make Amelia look bad when her younger rival overtakes her celebrity, but Amelia just throws the race anyway to empower all the ladies (fair enough) and then the young rival is never heard from again. Huh. She probably crashed into a mountain. Of boredom.

But perhaps the most incredible anti-climax of this movie occurs on two separate occasions when Amelia is trying to take off and it is unclear whether or not she will take off. Just to clarify: we are supposed to be on the edge of our seats on more than one occasion wondering whether or not an airplane will TAKE OFF much less GO ANYWHERE. Hint: sometimes it does take off and sometimes it does not take off! In neither case does it seem to matter EITHER WAY. (Also, again, we know that Amelia dies in the ocean, not in a take off accident. So, whatever? This movie might as well be Valkyrie, where we keep wondering whether or not Amelia will be the first woman to MURDER HITLER. Sometimes she does, sometimes she doesn’t. Then she cheats on her husband.)

I will say that I learned something from this movie. Did you know that Amelia Earhart had her own line of jumpsuits?

Neat!

Next week: Bride Wars. As always, please leave your suggestions in the comments or in an email. And if you haven’t done so already, please consult the Official Rules.

Comments (171)
  1. I am so glad that this recap appeared before I decided I actually had to watch the movie.

  2. (sings) “I’ve been waiting . . . for sooo long.”

  3. Don’t women ride horses too?

  4. “she was a pilot.”

  5. Just the pick-me-up/downer I needed aftr a long day of relative suckiness.

  6. Whenever Gabe closes a “Hey, What’s Up With Topher Grace” door, he opens a “Hunt for the Worst Movie of All Time” door.

    The Gabe giveth, and the good Gabe, he does take away.

  7. I wonder what werttrew is doing now.

  8. at first i thought the recap was not-so-good because nothing happened. then i realized (after all the bored mountain type jokes) that’s probably because nothing happens in the movie. so, thanks gabe, for enduring that because now i don’t have to. and werttrew? i hope this brings you closure.

  9. “Why do men ride horses?” Duh, because WILD HEARTS CAN’T BE BROKEN. Or something.

  10. Not to be the spelling police, but I think you meant “hurdles” and not “hurtles”, unless you are coining a new term to describe obstacles that are painful. In that case, you right.

  11. I wasn’t going to watch this movie but now feel compelled, just to find out what the Hell Richard Gere was so excited about. He was very excited!

  12. this made my day, week, month, and life complete. I’ve been waiting with bated breath! All year!

  13. WOHNDAFUL NYEWS

  14. I haven’t read the review yet I had to comment just to say, CONGRATS WERTREW! DREAMS DO COME TRUE.

  15. Excellent as always, but I literally can’t wait for this


  16. graphic courtesy of Lakonislate

    Dear Videogum Staff: I would like to thank you for reviewing the 2009 film Amelia, the biopic about aviatrix Amelia Earhart starring Hilary Swank and Richard Gere, for The Worst Movie of All Time. As you noted, this was a truly awful film.

    With every word of this review, I felt a pleasant, warm sensation. WONDERFUL, WONDERFUL REVIEW(S)! It resulted in mirthful laughter and frequent smiles. I felt relaxed and happy, and the deep scarring that resulted from this film can now finally heal. Were there tears of joy? No, because I’m a man and incapable of getting in touch with my emotions on a deep level and I don’t cry when I’m happy. But I was joyful, yes. Words can’t express my joy. But maybe a gif can?

    Yeah, reading this WMOAT of Amelia was pretty much like that. Thus closes my campaign to have this film WMOAT-ed, and unlike the film, this has reach a great and satisfying conclusion. Good day and thank you for all you’ve done.

    It has been a pleasure. Again, thank you.

  17. You know what would’ve probably made Amelia at least a little better? Adam Scott. I didn’t even realize he was in the Aviator until like, 3 days ago.

  18. Do you guys pronounce it “bi-opic” or “bio-pic”? I do the latter but once a friend pronounced the former and it wrinkled my brain.

  19. Hilary Swank kinda looks like Matt Damon.

  20. What about Eastbound and Down?

  21. Not saying it is bad (its the best!) but why haven’t you written anything about it?

  22. “I’m Not There” is a good biopic. But that’s about the only one.

  23. I misread “Bride Wars” as “Birdie Wars”, and I got so, so excited. Now I’m sad.

  24. Hidden due to low comment rating. Click here to see

  25. My favorite Amelia will always be:

  26. Hilary Swank is the real life version of that girl Jerry Seinfeld went out with on that one episode. You know, the one who looked kinda hot in one light, and looked like the Crypt Keeper in another. I don’t think I need to tell you which version we’re seein’ here.

  27. Between Amelia and Wallstreet Gabe is exposing himself to a dangerously high level of poor movie making that could have serious long term consequences. I urge caution on his part. There are many awful movies in the Hunt and there is no research on what high levels of exposure can do to ones taste in art.

  28. I only knew of Amelia Earhart because she was in this “Mysteries and Monsters” book I had when I was 7. And in it she crashed in The Bermuda Triangle and there was this rad picture of her on the bottom of the sea as a skeleton with seaweed all over her and she was wearing her aviator outfit. But that doesnt have anything to do with the movie.

  29. Gosh — I had forgotten this: on “Oscar Night,” a coworker of mine went to Astroburger, and the Swankstress herself was there, in her dress, holding her Oscar (for Million-$ Baby) and ordering something at the counter. He sneaked a photo of her back and brought it in. She put the Oscar down on the counter to pay. So I am a fan.

    This movie sounds terrible though. That “Wohndahfohl!” clip is priceless. I want to thank werttrew for his dedication and say that I am thrilled this feature is back in style. YES!

    • Whatever. I won 50 cents for winning the spelling bee at school in 3rd grade, and I set the 50 cents on the counter when I used it to purchase 5 plastic bears. (True story, don’t hate me because I can spell… or for my tiny plastic bear fetish.)

  30. I haven’t seen the movie and I only skimmed this review, but I’ve got to know… Did Amelia murder Hitler or not?

  31. I went back and reread the Biopics Suck article and would like to take a moment to officially announce that I am making the phrase “Shut up, Cod” a thing. Tell your friends.

  32. It was the Bermuda Triangle that finally got her. What with all the magnetic forces and UFOs and sea creatures. You’d have to be crazier than a man on a horse to go flying near there.

  33. Hidden due to low comment rating. Click here to see

  34. Can we have a Worst Actor of All Time?

  35. Wertrew, can I hire you to do my Videogum PR to get “John Tucker Must Die” nominated?

  36. I loved the picture of the cat playing upon the guitar the most. It is very funny.
    Natura Cleanse

  37. Now if I google my name it comes up “Amelia SUCKS”. Thanks guys. Thanks.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post, reply to, or rate a comment.